The Benefit Cosmetics EYE bright pencil works wonders, it works best with other makeup though. It leaves a faint purple, but not noticeable to others. I recommend this product to anyone who wants to try it. It's not a necessity, but it's nice.

I forgot I owned this pencil but now that I have rediscovered it, I find myself reaching for it every day! It really brightens my makeup look and makes my eyes pop.

This has always been my go-to pencil for the waterline. I do agree that it does not last very long and needs to be reapplied, and lazy application can mean bright pink lower eye lashes. A stick of this does last me months and months so I don't always mind the higher price tag. I do think when my current stick runs out I will try something at a lower price point.

I liked this pencil for the inner corner of the eye area and maybe the lashline.
If you add a bit to the inner corner of the eye and you smudge it just slightly to blend it in, it make yours eye pop and you appear more awake.

I barely go through pencils since I don't use them often, and I went through this one. When I finished it, I bought the Sephora brand one in a light lavender (which is almost identical to this one) because it was much cheaper. However, I would buy this again, since it is a good products.

Overall, I like Benefit as a company, they make decent products.

one of the better benefit products i've tried. i don't see it as being anything special, although it is creamy and smooth. i wouldn't repurchase it though, because surely you can find a nyx jumbo pencil (cottage cheese, maybe?) that gives the same effect.

Benefit is generally a wonderful make-up line- quality and pricing- but this "brightening" eyeliner is a disappointment. It's too pink and makes you look more hungover than fresh faced. Yikes! I recommend Almay's eye brightening eyeliners, instead.