Not my favourite mascara. It's too expensive and doesn't do anything different to my lashes than a drugstore mascara can do.

I got this from the Sephora birthday gift. When I first tried it, I noticed my lashes were double in volume and size. It was also stated that it was waterproof. However, throughout the day it smudges below my eyes like crazy. My friend used this product with no problem though. My eyes are naturally more oily I'd say so, that might of affected it.
I've tried using this product 3 times and every time it does the same thing.

After I heard people raving about this I was excited to try it. I was NOT impressed! I found it a bit clumpy, flaky and it made my lashes look weird. I've tried a LOT of mascaras, including some other Benefit ones, and most of them were better than this one.

For the price you pay I would expect to have it not flake. This product was horrible for its flakiness. This was not a match made in heaven for me. I was constantly removing flakes from under my eyes and it made my eyes itchy. I threw this product out after 4 uses. I do not recommend this product.

This makes my eyelashes look great but like most mascaras I end up having flakes with it. I will not buy again just for that reason.

The best mascara I've ever tired. I have naturally long and full lashes but this just excentuates what I have. The price is reasonable (around $25) for what you are getting. I would 100% recommend this to people who like long lasting length and volume without any flaking.

When I first bought this mascara I found it to be very thin and hard to build on. Now that I have had it for a few weeks and tried it a few times I think that air has gotten to it and has started to thicken it up. It works very well and the brush shape seems to work well in order to get to the base of the lashes. I find that 2 coats is perfect as if I try to do anymore, my lashes start to look a little spidery with this mascara. Definitely adds more length than volume but overall it is a great product!

Amazing mascara!!! This is my all time favourite, ever since I received a sample size for the Sephora Birthday gift. Gives fantastic volume that actually lasts, a bit pricey, but totally worth it in my opinion!

I found that this mascara plumped and seperated my eyelashes giving them a full look. The color pigmentation was amazing the black really pops. Also I found removing the mascara was easy, and no big mess.

I was really excited to try this mascara since I had heard so much about it, but I was very sad when I realized it's not what it's cracked up to be. It didn't lengthen my lashes any more than a cheap drug store brand would, and it didn't give my lashes volume at all. It really did look like I was wearing my usual brand of mascara. Because of the price and hype I expected so much more, but I definitely won't be buying this now that I know what it's truly like.