This eyeliner is really great, and very easy to draw cat-eye, it's hard to use at the beginning, but practice makes perfect! The black one is realllly black and it's easy to remove with oil-based makeup remover. I would repurchase it again if the price wasn't so expensive. I would recommend this, if someone is looking for product under 30$.

Cons: I realize that sometimes the product gets dried up. Pricey.

I use liquid eyeliner on a daily basis, and when this one first came out I was so pumped about it and got it the day it came out ... then returned it the next day. It was so awkward to put on, it was clumpy and pulled on my eyelid and almost hurt as if it was pinching my eyelid! I would much rather an eyeliner that glides on smoothly! Its a shame because I love Benefit producs and this one made me sad!

I have really oily eyelids and as cool as the applicator, it smudged like crazy for me. It did not even last 2 hours. I was really disappointed. The product was hard to get out and for the price I paid, there are much better eyeliners at a much cheaper price.

I'm a huge fan of the Benefit They're Real Mascara but this product was a huge disappointment to me... I was super excited to try something I've never seen in an eyeliner before: gel in pen form! I found this product hard to distribute without wasting and having to retry. As for application, I felt as if it was only useful for my wing and was too awkward and bulky to use on the lash line. The only good thing I have to say about the product is the pigmentation....however the rest of the cons make this product a total NO

As much as i love benefit cosmetics, this product was a total disappointment to me. The idea is great, but the product itself doesnt deliver the results that are promised. The formula is weird, it's supposed to be a gel but it is so dry and hard to apply on lids! I am always on the hunt for the best eyeliner but sadly it's not going to be this one, unless they fix the dried up issue. Also, for the price you pay, you should be able to expect a quality product.

This eye liner dries very quickly. It crumbles way too often and is quite tricky to use even for a make up artist of several years. Disappointing to say the least

I received this as a sample in a monthly sample subscription box and I had it for a while before I even opened it and so when I finally did I wished I never bothered at all in the first place. I don't understand if this is supposed to be the way it was when I tried it but it was horrible to say the least, it didn't even stay on the eye it kind of crumbled off.

This liner works well enough. It's not my favorite but I do use it quite a bit. I'm not a huge fan of the applicator but the formula is nice. I like the shade of black and find it is not too matte or shiny.

Omg save yourself the time, energy, and total frustration you'll experience when buying this eyeliner... just stay away. It has THEEE WORST applicator pen push up thing... you crank it and would expect a somewhat smooth gel would come out.... NAHHHH not happening.... its hard to apply and crumbles if you try to get a solid dark black line... which is kinda the point of gel and liquid liners

UGGGG I hated this product so much, it is awkward to use and the actual eyeliner balls up when applying. The only way I could use it was to squish some out onto a brush, so I might as well just buy a pot of gel eyeliner. This was so not for me at all!!!