I found it to think for my liking, and you basically need to buy the remover or have a good one handy if you mess up. (So points for it staying and not smudging) but other than that I wouldn't recommend it.

If you are into big eyeliner this will be good for you, me unfortunately am not.

once i learned how to use this ..as it is real fussy to use, it works great for defining your eyes and is smudge proof .. lasts a long time and great for thick to thin lines

I stink at applying eyeliner. The applicator can be a bit tricky. But the formula lasts a long time like 48 hours! It is really easy to do a cat eye with this liner

I love this eyeliner SO much, it stays on all day and has gone down in price

Although without a primer this liner can smudge for those of us with oily lids the application of They're real liner is fantastic. I never have a morning anymore where I'm struggling when one eye liner is thicker than the other.

Wasn't sure if the Benefit They're Real Push Up Liner was going to be a hit with me or not at first. In theory it sounded amazing! I'm so glad I took the time to test it out though! It took me a little practice to get the feel for the gel pen - but once I had practiced a few times - This liner is amazing!! It gives you a precise line, whether you are going for thin, thick or even cat eye. They're Real also has great staying power all day. I would definitely recommend the Benefit They're Real Remover to take it off at the end of the day too!

I hated this liner. Looked so good on packaging but does not go on smooth. So disappointed because I adore benefit products usually. Don't waste your money.

One of the best eyeliners I have ever used. Takes a bit to get ised to the applicator but totally worth it!

I love this eyeliner! It's waterproof which is great! The tip really helps with application and it's a gel liner which allows for smooth application.