This one is the one of my favorite make up remover when we in japan , i always use this everday im finish to work make my face clean and also you can see the different because its lighten your face and and its east to taking all of your make up or even mascara in your lashes even if your mascara is a waterproof too.. Also its not sticky in your face.. I buy this in japan and cost me like ¥1300 yen in the bottle and in refil its ¥800 yen but when we move here in states i always bought this in amazon or ebay..but kind of expensive because the last time i buy it in amazon its $13.00 for just a refil.but i dont know either in the other online site. But either way i still love this product so bad so i still pay for it.