I got this because I wanted a NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil but this was a cheaper alternative. I seriously regret it. It is a lot smaller in size than other jumbo pencils so really the prices average out. The product is not creamy at all. It does not have the same consistency as the NYX ones and feels more like a pencil than the cream shadow it's supposed to be. I got the opal one and although the colour is nice, it is really unpleasant to apply. Its also very sheer but I think that's the point so that was just my fault for not doing my research :P