I would like to preface with the fact that I looove bare escentuals bare minerals for face and eyes and have gotten many people hooked on the products. I decided to buy the mascara because I figured I loved the rest of the products so much that this would be the same. Boy, was I wrong! It not only was too wet and smudged after putting 2 coats on but it left clumps on lashes, which I hate. I would not recommend this product.