horrible horrible horrible! i have good eyelashes and this just ruined them, also being a contact lense wearer makes me extra picky, this mascara has little balls of clump as soon as i put it on, and while it stays on decently, the mascara at the tips of my lashes always falls off making flakes on my face or worse in my eyes.. the little clumpies also fall off during the day and do the same, and every time i blink more flakes! its a brand new tube so its not dried out.. the only thing i like about this is how it comes off, similar to the KissMe mascara, it stays bonded together and just pulls right off into little strings with water.. but definately not worth having black flakes all over my face and in my eyes