For the price the Quality is AMAZING I got the dark black and also the brown and I love it. it marks great on my eyes and it works wonders. It is a must buy!
I love how Dark it is But I don't like how it smudges after maybe an Hour of wear. I prefer the pencil over the liquid because they are easier to use, I like the length of the NYC Eyeliner pencil making it easy to handle & I loved that It came with a Sharpener
These reviews are the subjective opinions of ChickAdvisor members and not of ChickAdvisor Inc.