Absolutely my one and only choice for mascara

I've been using covergirl mascara for 12 years . I've tried other brands from covergirl to lose waiter and mac ect. And I always come back to my covergirl waterproof mascara .

Not what I expected

I am a loyal CoverGirl Mascara user. I have tried lots of high price mascaras but always come back to CoverGirl as I find it the best. So I was going South for vacation and needed a waterproof mascara. I purchased the Clump Crusher (green tube) and was extremely disappointed. It washed off with no effort and did not even need a make-up remover. This is not "waterproof" by any means at all.