We used these at first when my daughter was learning to potty train. She prefers the Magic Melon scent because it smells nice and yummy. I found that they were too think and small to wipe her bottom entirely. After two or three wipes the cloth would tear apart. The price for these are costly at $2.97 for 42count at Walmart. The quality is average; they could be thicker and bigger in size. The effectiveness is also average because the quality is not that great. Overall, we like using larger thicker flushable wipes from the competitor.