Lise Watier Feline Mascara HD drastically lengthened eyelashes without clumping but didn't provide any noticeable volume. I liked that the mascara had a very dark black formula but it smudged a lot and was difficult to remove the racoon eyes throughout the day. I would not recommend this mascara because it smudged a lot even though it creates really long, pretty lashes. If this mascara didn't migrate, I think this may have been my new favourite!