I am a huge eyeliner fan, I don't leave the house without it. I bought this eyeliner on a whim and it was the best eyeliner I have EVER used. It goes on super dark, and smooth. You can use it on your upper eyelid or your waterline. It lasts all day, fading a bit as the day goes on but still there. The only downside is that its too big to fit into most sharpeners so ive had a hard time sharpening it. I have used the black and the brown and both are equally good.

This eyeliner is creamy just as it should be rich in color (well. .. color my pencil is black;))