I bought this eyeliner on sale for ~$7 at Shoppers. On the back of my hand, it seemed really good. Very pigmented (like gel) and smooth application. However, on my eyelids it smudged very soon, even with eyelid primer. Not worth it. Super dark and smooth formula though. Possibly would work better if you don't have greasy lids like I do.
I love how this glides on so smooth. It doesn't tug or pull and it leaves nice sharp and dark lines. I got the black one and I thought it was so easy to put on and I thought it might smudge because of this but it did not. It held up to the test. I will be buying this from now on. It literally goes on like butter and lasts all day.
I love this product-it is so smooth and silky to apply (hence the name!) and stays put too. It is definitely a keeper!
These reviews are the subjective opinions of ChickAdvisor members and not of ChickAdvisor Inc.