Worth a try

This is a really great high-quality eyeliner that provides long lasting results. The only issue that I found is that it does smudge a bit but if that’s the look that you’re going for than this is great! Give it a try!

This is a fantastic, basic liner. The pigment is vibrant and goes on evenly with one stroke, even along the waterline! It's easy to smudge, easy to wash away, yet stays where you put it, even while sweating at work on busy days! Mac has made magic liner and supplied it at an amazing price

This is the only eyeliner I've been using for the past 10 years! I've bought many others but always end up sticking to this one. I use the color smolder and it's perfect. It goes on easily and smooth and lasts all day while working in a kitchen! Would recommend this to anyone! It also lasts a long time, 6 months +.

I find that most Mac products are very expensive. This one is expensive however I find it is he only eyeliner that actually stays all day. It is also very easy to apply.

I love that it's soft and easy to apply, but I hate that my sharpener pretty much destroys it (because it's soft)

I have this in "Teddy" which is a dark brown. The pigment is great and looks awesome on!

Recently bought Mac eyeliner...very easy application.....easy to remove....very good quality product

I do like this product, but find for myself, I only used it for short times, that is, it is not something that lasts quite long on my eyelids. I think that people who have oilier eyelids, it wears off easily. If I am going out for a short time, it is great as a quick touch-up, but for something longer lasting, I prefer the gel liner.

I have this colour in Teddy, which is my go-to brown eyeliner. While it is easy to use, I find it difficult to get a clean finish on the outside of my eye. Great eyeliner, but it is pricey.

I have heard a lot of great reviews on this product, so I thought I would try it out this summer. Unfortunately it was a bust for me. I bought the color Smolder, nice color. I can't use it on my waterline...doesn't last very long, smudges like crazy. On top of my lashes, I have to be careful how far and how thick, it runs up into my eye shadow. Perhaps this type of formulation is not suitable for my skin type? I may try it once again in the fall/winter when it's not so hot...but we will see.

I can give it high marks for the quality of the product though, nice texture, intense pigments for the color and it glides on easily.