I recently purchased an eyeliner through Mary Kay. I usually love their products and decided to try their eyeliner. The first one was delivered broken; they replaced it free of charge. Upon using the eyeliner, I discovered that I did not think it was not worth the $15 I paid for it. As I applied it, clumps of eyeliner were breaking off and sticking to my eye lid. It was VERY difficult to remove, even with eye makeup remover. Definitely will not purchase it again :(