It is good, but has changed

I dont know if its because Im getting older. This mascara has been around forever. Yes, it makes your lashes look great, but as the day goes on, it drags and black circles appear under your eyes. Constantly having to wash the back off throughout the day.

My mother has always used this mascara, and I will always use this mascara. It goes on clean without clumping and I have never ever had to use my brow comb to separate my lashes after application. I currently use an old wand from another brand that no longer exists because I don't like the triangle shape of the wand they supply, but the mascara itself gives me midnight black, sky high lashes with one stroke

I've been using this product for almost 1 year. I find at the beginning it goes on very clumpy, but the more you use it it seems to thin out and apply nicely. Lashes look long and full. it also does not run when you apply thick with lots of layers. Will continue to use this.

Mascara à petit prix qui allonge en douceur les cils. Je l'aime bien pour mes cils du bas car la brosse est très petite. Ne donne pas beaucoup de volume aux cils.

I love this stuff! I like the wand, it's pretty easily to apply the product with. The shade of black is great and intense, which is what I love for eyelashes!

J'aime la brosse et le prix. J'ai des longs cils au naturel et le problème avec ce mascara là sur moi c'est la tenue. Les pointes de mes cils ne restent pas bel et bien droites en place. Les extrémités finissent toujours par plier dans un sens en raison qu'il accroche sur mes sourcils... j'espère que c'est claire hahaha.

For the price this mascara isn't too bad. The brush is great the only thing I find is that it starts to flake during the day and sometimes by the end of the day I have black under my eyes from it. Great brush, not the best formula.

This is an average mascara. I have pretty sparse and short lashes, I find that these add pretty good volume and length to to my lashes. The formula is pretty thick and tends to get really clumpy which I personally don't like. I do get a bit of fall-out by the end of the day. However, it's really worth what you spend on it (about $4). I find that they have the best price at Walmart for this mascara.

I've been on the hunt for my favorite mascara, and this was on sale at Wal-Mart (which I know is not TOP quality make-up products but who wants to spend a fortune on mascara). Anyways, the price was great it was like $4, but I didn't like the way it made my lashes look (compared to other mascaras) Just not my favorite!

I honestly do not understand why this is one of the most popular loved mascaras on the market, even compared to high end mascaras. Every beauty editor recommends this but I just don't get it. My lashes are thin and sparse and I really need and want the blackest black possible plus a formula and wand that gives my lashes major volume for that fat thick voluminous lashes look. I don't get this at all no matter how many coats I use or even if I use an eyelash curler, which I am far too lazy to do. This formula is too thin for me. I think it's well loved because it's not clumpy, which is great, but this mascara is not for me. It wouldn't even make my top 20 list.