Maybelline Illegal Lengths Mascara Blackest Black

I have been using this for a few months and loved it while it lasted! I used it for the top lashes as a first coat, then I would apply a waterproof over it. It really lengthened my lashes and gave it volume. I assume the fibres really help to create extra volume. However, I recently have had to stop using this because I got a fibre stuck in my eye and it wasn't too pleasant which is why I cannot really give this an excellent rating, so be careful when applying.

Well I couldn't wait to try this product when I saw the commercials. I would recommend this to anyone who wanted to get a lengthened look, as it did the trick without making lashes look like ugly spider legs. However, there was little to no volume, I applied loads and curled my lashes and they still looked rather thin. If you want a lengthy natural look go with this mascara. If you're looking for a dramatic, bolder look this isn't the product for you.

I was super excited about this mascara when I bought it but it was a huge dissapointment. I ended up throwing it out. It was clumpy, the brush is terrible and my eyelashes did not look any longer than normal.

I'm a big fan of Maybelline mascaras to begin with - I found this to be a pretty good one. It definitely competes with lash stilletto in terms of length but not shine. No clumps which is great...however I do find that because it is a fibre mascara it flakes off quite a bit.

This mascara gave me some length but not enough to be amazing. I did not experience clumping which is good. But my lashes looked thin and it flaked. I would not buy this again.

I found that this mascara worked well for lengthening my lashes but I had to put on another mascara to thicken them. But I would still buy this again

Not quite illegal lengths, but did give a bit of length! I decided to try this new to me mascara as it was on for a great price and I had a coupon so I picked up two. I ended up having to give one away even though the mascara worked as an average mascara would my eyes were left irritated and feeling as though I had sand in my eyes so therefore no I cannot recommend this mascara

This is a relatively OK mascara. It lengthened a bit, but nothing too dramatic. It was too liquidy to offer any volume. I wasn't overly impressed with this mascara. "Average" is the perfect word when describing this mascara. It doesn't volume or lengthen more than a dollar store mascara would. I really didn't like the brush, I found it too soft and pliable. I prefer a hard mascara brush that pushes against my lashes and coats them better. I have to use a business card (or something equally hard) behind my lash line when applying with this wand.

I bought it from Walmart for about $10, and really, it wasn't worth the $10. This mascara would have received a thumbs up if the price was about $3 or so.

The one pro about this formula is it left my lashes soft and not hard or crumbly. It didn't do anything major for me, I wouldn't recommend this only because there are other better alternatives out there (such as Maybelline define-a-lash).