Brown is actually black

I got the forest brown colour and it was indistinguishable from the black. If I wanted black I would have bought black. Not impressed with the colour. Value was okay.

Usually my go to eyeliner from a drug store. I usually prefer to use a higher end eyeliner but if I run out or need a back up I will use this one. It goes on very smooth but I find that it smudges easier. The past 2 I have gotten have also been broken and it makes it difficult to put on the eyeliner when pieces break off.

One of the better drugstore eyeliners that I have tried.
I do prefer prestige brands, like Stila or Lise Watier over this one though.
I find it still smudges more in comparison to the higher end products.
It would like the color to be more bold also.

A good value eyeliner - variety of colors and goes on well. I do find that it doesn't apply on top of eye shadow that well though, which is disappointing

I love this eyeliner. I am also looking for an eyeliner that lasts all day. i hate going to the washroom at work and seeing a black line on my upper eyelid, and smudgy liner that does not stay put. This one is great, it stays on all day, and glides on easily. Definately one of my favorite eyeliners.

This is my go-to eyeliner!! It works well, has a great texture and is a great price!

This is a really nice eye liner. Goes on smooth, and I like how I don't have to sharpen in (but the only downside is that the end can get a little dull in shape to creates a thicker line than I would like.)

I really like how this eyeliner goes on. I find it much easier to use than pencil liners and love that I don't have to sharpen. It goes on smooth and is easy to apply lightly and then build up.

My one complaint about this eyeliner is that it's not entirely waterproof. It stays perfectly on my upper lid, but I find after a few hours it tends to smudge when applied to the outer corners of my eyes and my lower lash line. However, I have yet to find a mascara that doesn't do this on my watery eyes (including much pricier ones) so I keep going back to this eyeliner because of its ease-of-use.

I've found that sealing the eyeliner with a bit of powder or eyeshadow helps minimize smudging if you have watery eyes.

i bought this eyeliner because regular pencil liners never last on my waterline without me ending up with raccoon eyes! but this being waterproof, didn't help either. it still smudges off quite easily, although some of it does stay for a while, but it's still easy to remove even without makeup remover. but, if you are planning on using it on your lash line and not your waterline, it'll probably be fine. (:

First off, I have oily lids, and so far the only thing that remotely works well is MUFE.
That said, I got this in a bonus pack with the Stiletto Mascara from Walmart.
I love that it doesn't need sharpening therefore not as much waste.
And it does apply quite smoothly, no tugging at my skin.
But I personally found that it didn't last very well on my lower lash line, my waterline, or my upper lid.
It seemed to smudge fairly easily as well.
I would say that this lasted me...3 hours MAX before the lower lash liner transferred all over the place (Though I would actually say that eve at 2 hours, it didn't look very good).