Not sure...

I bought this to try it out and I like the pearlized black. The brush however was very long and skinny and that made it hard to maneuver. The brush also delivered too much product at once.

I love it !

I've been using this NYC eyeliner for 6 month non stop and I really cant go wrong with this ! Super black , pigmented and easy to apply ! I love the tip and its also helps if your a beginner in makeup to practice your eyeliner and you will get the best black cat liner ! I recommend it for you girls :) And its so affordable ! Whats better ?

For a 3 dollar eyeliner this is worth every penny. The formula is smooth and dries matte. If you have experience using the wand you can get a super sharp flick that a pencil just can't do. However, it isn't waterproof and can smudge really easily if you don't let it dry completely. I like to follow it with a waterproof liquid eyeliner just to lock everything in place.

Honestly, for 4-5$ its really good. Its very black let me tell you ! The only thing i kind of dislike is the brush. It's not thin and pointy enough :\ which will create a bigger line. And the formula is not super long lasting either, I mean it will last 5-6 hours, but definitely not form 8 am to 3 am the next day. But overall, it's a good liquide very black eyeliner :)

Most of the times I wear a cream eyeliner with a liquid eyeliner on top in order to impact the color. This eyeliner glides on very smooth and works great for that purpose. I usually purchase this either online or through one of the drugstores here. I have also got this at ulta and would definitely recommend.

This eye liner is really good and it goes with my NYC mascara

I was pleasantly surprised by this 3$ product! It last for 8 hours and the color was fairly opaque. I had to apply two coats in some areas bt for 3 $, it really is a great find. I needed somehing to get me by for the week and this wilk definately do it. Wont replace my hg eyeliner but i dont regret the buy.

For the price of this product I think its great for general everyday wear. Doesn't smudge, last at least 8-12 hours and very easy to use!