This is a definite must have in a make up collection works great.

This stuff is AMAZING!!!! I have tried many different brands of liquid eyeliners and it can be some expencive stuff! NYC costs about $4 and it is better then the $10 more expencive name brand products. I swear by this and have reccomeneded it to a lot of people. I wear liquid eyeliner everyday that I go out and its part of my "signature look" lol! Love this stuff and its a must have!!

NYC liquid eyeliner is packaged in a plastic blister pack on cardboard. Removal did not require power tools as some do! Very happy about that, as some blister packages can be a nightmare.This liquid liner flows beautifully and smoothly. Because the brush has such small bristles, I can draw a very fine line, or press a little harder and achieve a thicker line. I wear liner on my upper lid and sometimes below as well. I like this liner is best for the top, the bottom not so much. Putting on make for me is like an artist starting a fresh canvas and this product allows for detail and precision. Great product, very budget friendly, definitely recommend.

I love this NYC liquid eyeliner! It's totally affordable. It was very easy & quick to apply. I love that it's like a pen. It lasted a long time for me and it's waterproof (so far). However, it did take a little bit longer to dry when applied than my previous eyeliner. For this cheap price and good quality, I would definitely recommend it! xD

I've never used any other liquid eyeliner besides N.Y.C. This is an amazing product! Its perfect on the go. The formula is light but goes on bold black (amplifying my lashes and contouring my eyes) and one purchase will last me for months. The applicator is a fine tip brush so you don't need to use a lot of formula. You get a lot out of it for the $2 price point. I really like that it enhances my eyes. I only wish it was waterproof, as it does smudge under moisture, however, it doesn't crack and I barely need to retouch it.

I hadn't planned on buying eyeliner, and certainly not liquid eyeliner. I haven't used that since the 80's (age alert). I was walking past the NYC display and saw those 4 little letters that always stop us in our tracks...SALE. I remembered that I did love liquid liner in the summer months as it didn't melt and make me look like Rocky Raccoon. I LOVE this liner (not just because it was under $2) The brush is just the perfect length and the liquid is true black. One stroke and Im done!
I recommend this product :)

Been useing this product for 6 years now and i swear by it. its one of my favorite things.

This was the first Liquid Eyeliner I bought. I don't like pencil there hard to put on. It is very easy to put on you can get it everywhere. you have to put it back on about every 4 hour because its flakes out. But its a very good product.

Its a must have !!!

This eyeliner was one of my first makeup purchases, mostly because it was the cheapest liquid eyeliner I could find. Back then I was still experimenting with how to properly put on cosmetics and I fell in love with this product because the brush tip made the application so smooth and precise. To be fair, I hadn't tried much else other than cheap pencil liners, so I stuck with using this liquid eyeliner because it gave me a dramatic look without spending so much effort trying to get colour out of the pencils.

Over time, my skills improved and I even began getting compliments on the way I did my eyeliner. I started referring all my friends to this product, and it became a part of their daily routines as well (though they don't use nearly as much as I, because I have conservative friends who like subtle makeup). So yes, this eyeliner is extremely versatile.

I have been using this product for five years now, and I still do every day because it is so convenient and inexpensive. It may not be waterproof and it does flake if you leave it on for a long time without touchups, but it does a very good job for just a day of going out. I love this eyeliner and I will continue to purchase it, even though I can afford a much more expensive brand, because it does an impressive job for such a reasonable price.

I tried this a few times but just not used to using the liquid eyeliner, smudge a lot on me and feels very sticky.