I love how this eyeliner goes on and it lasts all day. It never smudges and it has an almost metallic sheen to the black, which shines in the light. I love the cost as well, as it doesn't break the bank!

I find that this is an ok eyeliner for short term use, if you want this to last, it will not. This also only gives a thin line when the bristles don't splay, and because the bristles are so long, there is a learning curve to this. This dries matte, but strangely enough it also bleeds when wet, and flakes off when dry. Also smudges when attempting to correct with a q-tip.

This eyeliner has a learning curve to it, the brush is not as sturdy as some of the other felt tip brushes on eyeliner, and so I found it hard to line a very thin line with this. The formula for this is matte, but it is flaky, and does not last very long. If you try to fix mistakes with a q-tip, the eyeliner flakes off. When wet, this runs, and is messy to clean up.

Great product! For only $3 it's such a great product and purchase. The brush in small and thin so you can get close to your lash line. It is pretty liquidy however but maybe that's because I've been using cream eyeliner for so long. Highly recommend though.

Great Product and easy to use however the price is a little more then i would like to pay for this product.

Price is great but I have allergies and this product causes my eyes to swell

Affordable and effective. Worth every penny. Provides a nice dark even line.

It works well and its cheap! However careful applying more than one coat, as it tends to flake.

I have used classical eyeliners for a while now, but recently I decided to try a liquid one. I chose NYc since their quality is widely appreciated.
1. The eyeliner, the liquid itself is really good. It stays for a whole day. Not like a usual pencil which you have to reapply.
2. If you did not have a previous experience with a liquid eyeliner you will probably cry and freak out since it is extremely difficult to make it look good. You have to be an artists.
3.The price is higher than for the conventional product.
To sum up, I would not recommend the liquid eyeliner, but NYC still does a good job.

Absolutely Love Love this stuff. Amazing