pretty good!

The lip liner is very smooth, soft and creamy it lasts a long time but you still have to reapply after eating or drinking something. Although I definitely love how creamy it is!

I really do like the basic lip liner. The colour and staying power is nice. Just a bit of a dry formula.

The retractable lip liner is waterproof and therefore does not budge. It is also more creamy and glides on better. Well worth the extra dollar or two.