I was excited when I found the Physician's Formula Plump Potion lipstick. I wanted to try the lip gloss, but didn't because the review's said it was too sticky. I bought it in Pink Rose Potion. The packaging is good, and I like the container. The shade itself is really nice, and though it tingles, I haven't seen a difference in the size of my lips when I put it on. So considering the price, a nice colour isn't worth it, I'm sure I can find the shade in another brand. Definitely won't be purchasing this again.