I bought these in colours grey, charcoal and black called "Smokey" and they're perfect! Shimmery, but not overpowered with glitter. Easy to apply, and they last all day! I got them at Marshalls for $5 and I'm so glad I got them! They really are great eyeliners!
I can't give my opinion on the price because it was gifted to me, but only 1 out of the 3 colours for the brown eyes set. But the brown eyeliner is really pretty, shimmery and soft. You can smudge it out if you want to give yourself a smokey eye look. I am not the biggest fan of the packaging though because it can break at the base if you put too much pressure.
These reviews are the subjective opinions of ChickAdvisor members and not of ChickAdvisor Inc.