This liner is pretty expensive, it's about $25 at SDM but you do get a pencil liner with a complimentary liquid liner so it does somewhat even out so it doesn't seem that bad.
Like I said, you get two separate liners and one of those is a pencil liner. The pencil liner is retractable which is nice, you don't need a sharpener but the lead is very thick and big. This liner is only really ideal for "dramatic" or "bold" looks, I don't think you can achieve a thin line or something natural/precise just because it is pretty big. It does apply very smooth though, glides effortlessly and the colours are all highly pigmented. Make sure you put the cap on securely though because the lead does dry quickly and then it does not apply as well. Unfortunately, the pencil liner does smudge quickly and if you touch it at all it is ruined.
The liquid side, however has a thinner "felt" tip brush but also still applies smooth and pigmented. This side of the product stays much longer than the pencil liner. This doesn't smudge at all and it does seem to "stain" your lid and is a little hard to remove without a quality eye-makeup remover.
I do like all of the colours in the line as well, they are mostly blues/greens, one purple and a few neutral shades like black/charcoal/brown. They are all very bright also and a few of them almost have a "metallic' look to them and for the most part, all of the liquid and pencil liners compliment each other well except for one. "Queensland" has a light aqua-type colour for the liquid liner and the pencil liner is more close to a dark navy blue and to me, these colours do not match or go well together at all but all the rest go together very nicely and naturally.
These reviews are the subjective opinions of ChickAdvisor members and not of ChickAdvisor Inc.