Difficult to use

I bought this from Sephora when it was on sale. I usually use their regular black eyeliner which I love. This looks great when you do the first swipe... but if you're doing a winged liner or straightening up the line - anything where you have to go over the same spot with liner, you'll mess it up. The liner moves around and basically wipes off and it becomes gray. It's a little difficult to work with it but I still manage to wear this on a daily basis!

I was excited about this product when I first purchased it. The applicator looked similar to some of my other favorites. It went on well at first but it faded out quite a bit to the point that it looked washed away. Definitely not what I wanted in a waterproof liner.