This eyeliner was awful for me. Dragged my lid quite a bit getting it on, making it difficult to apply. The color payoff is so-so, it's not an intense black. Worst part, throughout the entire day, the eyeliner smudged so much underneath my eyes and trying to clean it everytime was a hassle. I have tried many liquid eyeliners before and none smudged at all like this one did. It was an awful experience.

This eyeliner pen is awful. It's a headache to try to use. When I press it on my hand, it comes out smooth and dark ... trying it on your eyelid is another story. It was a fight to even get some out of it. I absolutely hate this eyeliner and would never buy it again. It's honestly the worst eyeliner I've ever tried - thank god it was only a sample in my Ipsy Bag.