Penny Lane is my new favorite eyeliner.

I purchased Smashbox always sharp Waterproof Kohl Liner in the color Penny Lane and I absolutely love it. It's a neutral brown which is my preference when it comes to eyeliners and it is creamy and goes on smooth. I absolutely love the fact that the twist top cap has a built in sharpener which keeps your liner on point at all times. It lasts the day and even though it's waterproof it is easy to remove. I don't find it smudges or transfers throughout the day. Although this liner is quite pricey and seems to only last a few weeks with daily application I am still interested in trying other colors.

Really Liked it but maybe not Love

I did like this eyeliner. Was very handy to have the self sharpening built in but I did find that it still did transfer onto my eyelid after a full day of wear. I would buy it again but it for sure wasn't my favorite eyeliner that I have ever used.

Smashbox eyeliner

I've tried multiple Smashbox Always Sharp eyeliners now and they don't seem to disappoint. They go on easily and font wear off throughout the day. Sometimes, I have to reapply if I'm going out in the evening but otherwise it stays on well. I have had problems with the built in sharpeners but in general, I have liked the product.

This one takes a bit of skill to get used to using. But once you get it figured out, it's amazing. It last for hours, and doesn't smudge. Goes on smooth. Just make sure you close the container or kiss your money goodbye

an okay product. its not waterproof even though it claims it is. also is not verycheap. i Returned mine. the only interesting part is that it is ALWAYS SHARP.

I love how the product doesn't pull on the fragile skin of our eyelids. As we get older this is an extremely important feature to consider when shopping for eyeliners. It wears well all day.

Leaves a sharp, defined line all day. Very difficult to smudge but easy to apply. Doesn't burn or irritate eyes at all.