This is the only liquid eye liner that I use. It holds all day, and doesn't smudge. I've had mine for well over a year and it hasn't even started to dry out. It is well worth every cent and I will never change brands. I've tried so many different brands, and this one blows them out of the water.

This is definitely my favorite eye liner it doesn't run like alot of others its water proff and lasts for hours without having to reapply and the price is very fair for the quality you are getting.

One of my favorite liquid eyeliners. Easy to use, lasts forever and does not budge until I take it off. Ot also does not irritate my uber sensitive eyes which is a big problem for me with many eyeliners and mascaras.

I've been using Stila All day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner for two years. I highly recommend it because it never smear in my eyes and it stays longer. I have tried other brands but Stila all day waterproof eyeliner is the best for me since I have have oily skin.

Ok so this was the first liquid eyeliner I ever purchased. I do not like this and the reason for that is because its way too expensive for a product that just dries out after 2 weeks. Honestly, I don't like these eyeliner pens because they run out and dry up after 2 weeks of using. I prefer buying the cheaper eyeliners since I always have to keep buying more!

I don't typically use liquid eye liner often, but with a lot of practice I was finally able to use this stuff without making a huge mess! The felt tip definitely makes it easier to apply, and it is seriously smudge proof!

This is my first liquid eyeliner so there isn't much that I can compare. I purchased it during a warehouse sale because it was nearly half the retail price and my friend loves this so I figured if it didn't work for me I could give it to her. All I ask for in an eyeliner is long-lasting and smudge-proof and this pretty much has it down. I wear makeup for ~12 hours and this stuff holds up. This never fails me and it's fairly easy to control how thick of a line you want. Like I mentioned before, this is my first liquid liner so I do struggle to make the line I want but this is more of a user issue rather than the product itself. I would definitely repurchase this.

I had a lady recommend this for me at Shoppers when I asked for something simple, straight-forward that I won't be allergic to. It is extremely easy to put on and remove. I cannot imagine going back to crayon eyeliner after my experience with this.

I was trying to decide between trying this liner and buying my old drug store brand again, and I'm glad I got this one. The tip of this liner is so fine that you get a precision line every time. The felt tip makes it easy to make it a thick or thin line, and the staying power is amazing! I love that it's like using a pen to draw! I will purchase this again once it runs out.

I have oily skin, and the "stay all day" liner did not live up to its name for me. I had to re-apply/fix many times throughout the day because it would smudge and give me raccoon eyes.