I LOVE this liner, it's the perfect consistency, and doesn't smudge, dries matte!!! I don't like the brush though, I use a different one to apply it.

I love Tarte. My ultimate fav brand. I love this eyeliner. I've had it in many different colours. I've never had a problem with it smudging or wearing off. The brush it comes with is perfect for applying, however I tend to gravitate to my other eyeliner brushes a lot. The only complaint is that it will eventually start to dry out, but that took about a year, which is right about when it should be replaced anyway.