I was very excited to try this product, however I was let down! This eyeliner, did not even last an hour without begin to fade away in certain spots making it look uneven and cheap. It looked fantastic when first applied, the color payoff was great, but it was far from durable. This was a highly raved product, yet did not meet the standards in my book. It rubbed off and became a mess. For the price which was on the higher side, I was let down and will not be repurchasing.

For a product that promises 24/7 UD really falls short! Smudges so much I need to wipe off and reapply within a few hours. I only buy for the pigmentation quality.

I received a sample of this in an Ipsy bag, and generally I'm not a fan of pencil liners, I find them hard to use as they tend to pull. I find it tough to get a solid clean line and no matter how i try I can't seem to sharpen them without a bit of the wooden part of the pencil stabbing at me. However this was billed as 'velvety' so I gave it a whirl. I seem to have to work really hard to get a solid black line and then I still find I need to fill in with a bit of eyeshadow and more amazingly it leaves little bits of black all over my under eye and the tops of my cheeks. I have no idea what this retails for, and as it's Urban Decay I assume it's not under $10. This is a pass for me because it takes too long to use and sheds bits of black on my face.

I had high hopes fir this one but unfortunately it fell short, the colour of these pencils are highly pigmented but felt like they smudged to easily and they do not last for hours

For a well known and expensive brand, this eyeliner is not good at all. It is very hard to sharpen and it does not last long. I end up with black flakes all around my eyes. I would not recommend at all.