Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Find reviews on:
Sort by:  

41-60 of 813

NYC HD Trio Eye Shadow
I recently received samples of this eye shadow and it's awesome. The colors are matte and earthy and really make your eyes stand out. They don't smudge either.

5 reviews
Maybelline Blushed Nudes Palette
A bit sheer but still worth every penny. This is my new everyday palette, full of warm pink and plum shimmers and beautiful transition taupes.

3 reviews
Makeup Geek eyeshadows
Something to know about me is I have a love and adoration for Stila eye shadows With that being said I am having an affair with Makeup Geek shadows!! shhhhhh for serious thought if I can be real. These are some of the most pigmented amazing shadows that you can get for under...

1 review
Tarte Tartlette Amazonian Clay Matte Palette
Gorgeous, I just love this palette so much! It has 12 matte shadows that are so smooth, like butter, to apply, and so many endless combinations in which to wear them! Every shade is usable, including the black named Fashionista, which I've used as an eyeliner & also to help...

1 review
Makeup geek shimashima
I love love love this eye shadow, a great champagne color!!! Its perfect as a high lighter for the brows and the cheek bones!!! Its worth it!!!

1 review
makeup geek crupt
Excellant price and its just as good as Mac eye shadows!!!

1 review
Colour Pop Super Shock Shadows
This shadow cost $5 totally worth every bit and more great color great feel stays put absolutely one of my favorite shadows

3 reviews
Kat Von D Monarch Palette
Kat Von D's products are amazing! I love this neutral palette of colors. She has quality ingredients and the products stay on where you put them.

7 reviews
Milani Shadow Eyez
This is a great eye shadow pencil in golden bronze that I actually found at the Dollar store. I have saw this same brand at other stores for more than $1. It is a very subtle bronze color that last all day without smudging. It is easy to apply and doesn't tug at the eye area.

1 review
Elizabeth Arden Beautiful Color Eye Shadow Quad - Chic Browns
This palette is rich and warm. You can choose to create a subtle or dramatic look. A mix of perfectly coordinated shades in shimmer and matte finishes. Love the smooth texture of this eye shadow. It also has an insert that shows you where to use the specific colours. A...

1 review
Elizabeth Arden Beautiful Color Eye Shadow Quad - Posh Purples
Luxurious eye shadows that are perfectly coordinated shades in shimmer and matte finishes. Goes on smoothly and stays on your eyelid without flaking. Feels light and soft. Quality applicator that doesn't come apart. Such a beautiful case that keeps everything clean and...

1 review
theBalm Nude Dude Eye Shadow Palette
This palette is so cute - the packaging and design is on point. I love the neutrals as well... however, the quality could be better. There are a few colours that don't blend well and aren't pigmented (tend to flake off as well). On the whole, this palette is not as good quality...

3 reviews
Quo beauty contest box
I love shoppers drug mart brand , this kit comes with 13 eye shadows, 4 gel eyeliners, 2 Big blushes & applicators all for $30.00. I love the colours they stay on all day. And it's in a neat little jewelry type box.

1 review
Kat Von D Innerstellar Palette
worth every penny the quality is so good definatly will be buying again just amazing

3 reviews
BareMinerals The Magic Act Palette
The palettes shades are a warm dusky rosy natural eye look. The shadows range in color from dusky pinks to taupe, and beautiful rich browns. The Ready Shadow formula is beautifully textured. It’s velvety, buttery, and smooth! It applies easily on lids without fall out issues...

1 review
Tarte Poppy Picnic Amazonian Clay Eye Palette
Wow, I don't think I've ever come across a palette that is so beautiful! There are 6 gorgeous eye shadows & one blush named Glisten which is a peach pink colour, and all are made from their Amazonian clay that Tarte is known for. Yes, they are nude mattes, but they are also so...

1 review
Makeup Geek Foiled Eyeshadows
Love these eyeshadows. Amazing for the price, better than most high end eyeshadows. Pigmentation is great, no fallout when applying.

2 reviews
Quo Spring 2015 Collection
Quo is my stand by, I use it almost every day. Especially love the multi colour sets. Matte or shimmer doesn't matter, it lasts all day. Highly recommend their brushes to apply their blush and eye-shadow. Usually buy mine around Christmas time, best prices.

3 reviews
Essence Smokey Eyes Set
These tiny little palettes include three shades of shadow each with an applicator to create a simple, easy smoky eye in a few steps. I’m of the mentality you don’t need twenty different eyeshadows to create one look! This little palette includes the essentials which are a...

1 review
BH Cosmetics Wild Child
This palette is one of my go to when, I want to achieve the perfect day time look . The colours are perfectly pigmented and goes on smoothly.

1 review

The Hot List

Trending products on ChickAdvisor curated by our members & advisors.