Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Find reviews on:
Sort by:  

41-60 of 1037

Batter Up Long Wearing Eyeshadow Stick by The Balm Cosmetics
These cream shadow sticks are very long lasting, work great as a base for powder shadow, look great worn on their own and come in a range (8) of beautiful very wearable shades. They cost a reasonable $17 each. I definitely recommend and I will be purchasing more!

1 review
Hard candy look pro sassy eyes eyeshadow palette
My daughter made me purchase this at walmart. She said it would look good on me, personally I think she just liked the pink tin. Lol. So I opened it up and there is a tube of eye shadow primer (bonus) and 9 different palettes of color an application brush and an eyeliner pencil...

1 review
Maybelline New York color tattoo 24HR Leather by Eyestudio creamy beige
I got this on sale for about 7$ at my local drugstore. Usually I think it's about 11$ so it's quite a bargain. I have very light skin and sometimes creamy eyeshadows that are not pastels look too dark on my face. This one is perfect. It's a light matte brown very easy to play...

1 review
Cover Girl Nudes Eye Shadow Palette
I have very light skin so this palette compliments my skin wonderfully, blends well and even has the darker shades if you'd like to do the smokey eye. I love this especially cause all of the shades match my brown eyes and it lasts through the whole day, no need to re apply

2 reviews
CoverGirl trunaked Roses Eyeshadow Palette
This is my current absolutely favorite product!! If I had a box subscription company this would be my gift for the month! I actually gave it to my best friend as a part of her wedding gift! It's that amazing!! She loved it too! Can believe the perfection of the color choices...

6 reviews
essence 2 in 1 eyeshadow and liner
Beautiful shimmery colours that work as an amazing base for eye shadow! super pleased with how easily they swipe on with no mess! Since they are a cream however, they do tend to crease a bit, so like to set mine with a bit of translucent powder. Can't beat the price though!

1 review
CoverGirl Eye Shadow Palette
Comes out darker than it appears Don't put so much on Could probably use as zombie makeup to A pretty good smokey I can come out so it A nice inner corner colour in it.

12 reviews
Almay intense i-color shimmer-i for Greens
I purchased this on a whim because I was really drawn to the deep emerald crease colour that I find goes well with my dark brown hair. I was so pleasantly surprised by the quality and pigmentation of these shadows! The green especially as I've hardly made a dent in because it is...

1 review
NYX Roll on shimmer
The NYX roll on shimmer is super sexy, very pigmented I love it! The price is super cheap!!! There is a lot of colours, my favourite is the chestnut, Walnut, Taupe and Nude. There really beautiful if you love shimmer or glitter you will love these.

1 review
Tarte Cosmetics Color Vibes Amazonian Clay Eye Shadow Palette
For $60 you get 20 full sized shadows in gorgeous mattes, shimmers and satins. Features a full sized mirror. Amazonian clay formula is richly pigmented, buttery soft and also benefits the skin. Love this palette!

1 review
Stilla Eyeshadow Palette in Spirit
I just love the palette colours and the good quality of this eyeshadow. I don't wear eyeshadow every day but I'm kind of using it more often because the colours in this palette are very beautiful, this product is definitely a must have in your make up haul

5 reviews
Maybelline Expert Wear Golden Halo
I love love this Maybelline Golden Halo eye shadow. The pigmentation on this is amazing it last all day and night. I use it in my tear duct for that pop of gold when i'm wearing a bright lip. It so bright.

1 review
CoverGirl Eye Enhancers Brown Smolder Eyeshadow
If you have brown hair and brows or want a good, inexpensive contour eyeshadow, you need to add this to your makeup kit. It is so versatile. I've used it to achieve a smokey eye look, to fill my eyebrows and I've also applied it as a liner to my lids. The consistency is smooth...

1 review
Too Faced Love Palette Eye Shadow
I've always been a huge fan of Too Faced Cosmetics products. The eye shadow "Love" Palette is just exceptional! I believe everyone whom loves beauty products and makeup should own one of these palettes. It is a beautifully designed palette with the shadows in a heart shape. It...

1 review
Urban Decay Eyeshadow - Fireball
I got this eyeshadow as a sample in my Sephora order. I have yet to try this colour, but I'm excited to try it. It's one of those classic colours that you can wear with anything. I'm 100% the quality of the eye shadow is great just because of the past experiences. I doubt anyone...

3 reviews
Covergirl TruNaked The Goldens Eyeshadow
I recently got this as it was on sale. I love all the colours. It has a a good trasnsiton colour and some good lid and highlight colours as well. It also has some darker colours to create that beautiful brown smokey eye. paired with a black eyeliner it creates beautiful looks...

5 reviews
Avon eye dimension eyeshadow
This eyeshadow is amazing! You only apply one time and it goes on thick. Easy to apply with three colors to play with. Great price for a great product.

1 review
Charlotte Tilbury Eyes to Mesmerise Cream Shadow
I have tried cream shadows at varying price points, including luxury cream shadows and Charlotte Tilbury's are my favorite. They are thick and creamy; application is easy, and the shadows are easy to blend. They are pigmented and the colors are super vibrant on the eye, and have...

1 review
Urban Decay Eyeshadow in Baked
I loved the colour. I would have gotten the palette which was $60 plus but more than half of the colours I wouldn't wear. So I got one for around $20+ Absolutely love the slight shimmer and how it is easy to apply. One of the best colours I have picked too date

1 review
Urban Decay Skull Shadow Box
This was the very first Urban Decay product I bought, when I was just eighteen and didn't have a Sephora near me. I had my parents drive me two hours out of town to get to the nearest one, where I found this palette and began my love affair with the brand. Although this...

1 review

The Hot List

Trending products on ChickAdvisor curated by our members & advisors.