Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Find reviews on:
Sort by:  

41-60 of 728

Kat Von D Monarch Palette
Wow I got this eyeshadow a week ago and I have had so much fun using it! There are so many different shades in this palette set. I have tried out all of them and they all look so amazing. I mean who wouldn't want to look like Kat Von D?

5 reviews
e.l.f. Cosmetics Little Black Book Eye Shadow Palette
Before I bought the product, I was told that Elf creates horrible makeup products. I still wanted to give it a try so I did. I bought the black book on sale for $5 at TJ MAX. It was definitely worth it. I found the colors to be very nice and applied on my skin so easily. I have...

2 reviews
Pixi by Petra
I got this in apricot glow and it's beautiful! It's so pigmented and smooth. It doesn't look dry or powdery on the eyes, and it's shimmery and rich in colour. A great quality product!

1 review
Kat Von D Shade Shifter Eye Shadow
I purchased On the road which is the brown with green shift, it's gorgeous except on my fair skin it's not brown it's a coppery gold metallic almost a burnt orange which works well with my hazel eyes and the green only shows if you build on it, it's still pretty but I was hoping...

1 review
Quo Spring 2015 Collection
I love the seasonal Quo collections. I've said this before and I'll keep saying it, I don't know why Shoppers doesn't promote Quo more. It's got decent quality products for a good price. I'm a fan of their powdered products in particular eyeshadows and blushers. I've haven't...

1 review
Colour Pop Super Shock Shadows
Color pop super shock shadows are made in California and each shadow costs only $5 each, that's way less than drugstore brands here in Canada! the shadows are super creamy and soft for a powder, they offer an amazing colour payoff as well. I purchased Hustle and Hanky Panky and...

1 review
Lili Rouge Eye Touch
Eye touch! is a loose powder eye shadow with really strong pigments and that s why I love it! The color You see is the color You ll get. It can be use on your cheeks and lips as well, it s also use for body painting since You can use it demp. Intense pigments that last at least...

1 review
Rimmel London Glam Eyes Smoky Noir 00
Rimmel Smoky Noir 00 is a seductive palette that combines black and silvery hues. It’s the perfect eye shadow quad to give you a sexy and smoky look. The colour blends beautifully and stays on your eyes. I love to pair this palette with CoverGirl Liquiline Blast Eyeliner in...

1 review
Rimmel London Glam Eyes State of Grace 02
Rimmel’s State of Grace 02 is a gorgeous palette that combines blues, violet and silvery white. The eye shadow goes on beautifully and stays for hours. The eye shadows blend very well and do not sprinkle under your eyes. I love to pair this palette with CoverGirl Liquiline...

1 review
Wet N Wild Color Icon Single Shadow in Nutty
This brand of cosmetics is so affordable and available at my local Dollar Store. It comes in all kinds of colors and it does stay on throughout the day.

3 reviews
e.l.f. Cosmetics Duo Eye Shadow
I love this eyeshadow! It goes on smoothly, the two colours in each compact blend beautifully and my vegetarian daughter and I both like that the e.l.f. brand is not tested on animals.

1 review
Rimmel London Glam'Eyes HD Eye Shadow, Brick Lane
Rimmel is very likely one of my all-time favourite brands, but somehow they end up overshadowed by the Sephora-bought items in my collection. I recently purchased this lovely little fiver on sale at the drugstore and immediately fell in love. The colours are probably perfect on...

1 review
Younique Mineral Eye Pigments
So nice and it stays more than other companies.

2 reviews
MAC Cosmetics Eye Shadow in Handwritten
This is a highly-pigmented shadow that is a MUST-HAVE colour!! It blends so well in the crease for ANY look, and is a real standard in day-to-day makeup looks. It's a pretty deep brown colour so it's perfect in accentuating the crease and outer corner to make your eyes look...

1 review
Lush Sophisticated
Lush cream eye shadow is easy to use, gorgeous, and very gentle on my eyes. You can make it more subtle for the day, or more dramatic for the evening - I loved it!

1 review
NYX Hot Singles Eyeshadow
Easy to apply and good pigmentation. Lot's of colours to choose from which I love when I find a good shadow.

3 reviews
Hard Candy Natural Eye Palette
Comes with 9 eyeshadows, eye primer, and eyeliner. The shadows are pigmented and blendable. Also the shades are similar to Too Faced natural eyes The primer is just as good as high end eye primers. The eyeliner sucks but I wasn't really counting on it working out.

1 review
essence Metal Glam Eye Shadows
Love these. Bought the pink/gold colour and went back for the brown.

3 reviews
Too Faced The Return of Sexy Eyeshadow Palette
These are 3 of Too faced best selling colour combinations and they are amazing! It comes with an instructional of a day and night instructional for each look. PERFECTION! I love the tutorials.

1 review
coastal scents eye shadow
The colors I have in this pallet are Nude, Amber bronze, platinum blue and opal black. What I love about this is that it almost feels like a liquid to powder type eyeshadow. the colors come out very vibrant when applied and I don't get a wrinkle when I apply extra to make it...

1 review

The Hot List

Trending products on ChickAdvisor curated by our members & advisors.