Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Find reviews on:
Sort by:  

41-60 of 1011

Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance Palette
To start off the velvet package is really nice however it easily shows smudges.The eyeshadow formula is amazing, its very smooth and very bold. I find the formula in this palette has improved from their old palettes. If you have never used this palette before you'd notice the...

2 reviews
CoverGirl trunaked Roses Eyeshadow Palette
Very complimentary to brown eyes. I have brown-almost black eyes and purples help make them look more gorgeous. I love the formula. The price point is good for someone who is looking for a high end look but on a budget. There is a little bit of fall out, but you can avoid that...

5 reviews
Mary Kay Mineral Eyeshadow - Azure
For just $9 (Canadian), you can have a cute, fun, long-staying eye colour. And: It's a Mineral Powder Eye Shadow!! How perfect is that? Light-weight, great coverage, and a super colour!

3 reviews
Maybelline The Rock Nudes Eye Shadow Palette
For someone just starting out makeup, I like this option because you can do a multitude of looks. The colours are cohesive which is a huge plus. Regardless of eyeshadow, for the best results make sure you have a flat brush to apply your base, and a fluffy brush for your crease.

4 reviews
Kat Von D Monarch Palette
I really like this pallet. First the packaging is just really beautiful to look at. Also the quality of the eye shadows are top notch. :D There can be a bit of fall out but your eye look will stay all day. (I do use primer) The colors are really pretty and make my blue eyes...

13 reviews
BH Cosmetics 88 Matte Shades Palette
BH Cosmetics is an amazing makeup line with fantastic pricing. I purchased the 88 Matte Shades Palette and I am absolutely obsessed! There are so many different colours and so many possible looks to come from this palette. The shadows are super pigmented. Very soft, you barely...

1 review
W7 In The Buff Eyeshadow Palette
I bought this palette for less than $9 on Amazon after reading positive reviews on makeupalley and it is definitely one of the best purchases I've made all year! It's not a perfect dupe for the Urban Decay Naked palette but the colors are pretty similar and it's a great value...

1 review
anastasia self made palette
Hands down best palette ever!! I've been using this for pan that palette in 2016 and have been able to create so many looks. There's a great combo of colorful and neutral shades. The shades are extremely pigmented and blendable. Must try!

1 review
Dr. Hauschka Eye Shadow Palette
I bought this on a whim when I was ordering some of their skincare products and now it's the only eyeshadow I use. I wasn't expecting it to work as well as it does because it's natural. The quality is comparable to high end eyeshadow and lasts all day. No creasing, blends...

1 review
Urban Decay Deluxe Eyeshadow - Toasted
My go-to eyeshadow for several reasons: - It flatters my skintone - It has a slight shimmer Beautiful bronzed color that looks super natural. Originally in the Naked palette. Long lasting and pigmented. One of my favorite shades that I keep going back to.

1 review
CoverGirl Eye Shadow Palette
very nice colors. buildable, and well priced. I do love cover girl and the eyeshadow is no exception great for trying a new color you're unsure of or great price for people like me that can't afford 75 bucks for eyeshadow

10 reviews
Too Faced Peanut butter and jelly palette
I love the name of these eyeshadows! Toofaced always has the cutest packaging. The colours work great. They are pigmented but easy to blend. You can create a lot of looks from daytime to a smokey eye. The price was okay, but I wish it was cheaper so I could pick up a second one...

2 reviews
Naked 3 Palette Urban Decay
This is an amazing eyeshadow kit. I love it, although I do wish the colours popped more when applied with primer. The eyeshadows don't crease so it's great.

3 reviews
Mary Kay at Play Neopolitan Baked Eye Trio
I bought this and got 3 years out if it till I dropped it. Even then it all didn't shatter and go everywhere. Color very nice perfect for sensitive skin. And color stayed a day. Also I found the colors didn't blend together

9 reviews
Stilla Eyeshadow Palette in Spirit
Lasts all day with amazing pigment love the colors and how they mix and blend. I love all stilla products and have yet to be disappointment. Def a lifer over here!!!!

4 reviews
Covergirl eye enchancers shimmering onx
I don't wear make up very often and when I do I have to get someone else to put it on me because I'm clueless when applying makeup. This was one of the first eye shadows I purchased and I wanted it for a cat eye look and it looked really nice when it was applied (by someone...

1 review
Estee Edit The Edgiest Kohl Shadowsticks
The product is housed in a slim plastic packaging that twists up. When you open it up, the tip is presharpened but it will get duller as you use it up. The end of each stick has a color coordinated cap so you can easily tell what shade you are picking up. The packaging feels fun...

1 review
Pacifica natural mineral eye shadow trio
I am not normally an eye shadow person I received this one in my ipsy bag I was happy to try it. It went on nicely and looked great. I like the fact it is 100% vegan and cruelty free. It lasted throughout the day Looking fresh like I had just applied it,

1 review
Kiko Milano Water Eyeshadow
This particular eye shadow can be applied both wet and dry, so it is versatile, and can easily be dressed up or down. When used wet, the color is a lot more vibrant ad dramatic, as well I've noticed that the staying power is also greater. When used dry there is a little bit of...

1 review
Urban Decay Eye Shadow | Virgin
This eye shadow is $22 for 0.05oz of product at Sephora. Virgin is my favourite colour to use as a base for pretty much every eye look I do. It's great for just simple natural looks, classic winged liner and red lips or a highlight for smoky eyes. Great pigmentation, it's a cool...

1 review

The Hot List

Trending products on ChickAdvisor curated by our members & advisors.