Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Find reviews on:
Sort by:  

41-60 of 520

NYC eyeshadow "long sands beach"
These three colours are gorgeous! I have brown eyes and these shades work perfect. Plus the price is super too! I can do a lighter smoky eye or use the lightest shade to highlight just for an everyday look!

1 review
Sweet Recipe Cupcake Eyes
Two-toned eye shadows baked and infused with pearl to supply sweet shimmer and color Mouth Watering Desserts & Eye Popping Colors

1 review
almay shadow softies eyeshadow
These shadows remind me of Play-doh in the container, but they go on like a powder and give a very soft look. I do not find them to be hard to work with like most people have implied. I use 2-3 swipes and I have a nice color. I maybe would prefer to use a brush but I find my...

2 reviews
CoverGirl Eyeshadow - Smoke Alarm
I love Covergirl and Smokey Colors. Grey and silver tones. You can trust the quality, and a great price, too. I've stocked up! :)

1 review
Bourjois Smoky Eye Kit
Available at Shopper's Drug Mart, this handy little palette includes really well described instructions on creating a natural looking smoky eye. Stays on all day, and doesn't crease or bother my contact lenses. It is a beige, brown palette which my make up consultant tells me...

1 review
Coastal Scents Revealed Palette
I bought this product after seeing some YouTubers using it. They said it was a cheaper alternative to the Naked 1 and 2 palettes because it had shades from both of them. I do not have the money for those palettes so I thought I would give it a try. I purchased it on sale for...

1 review
Balm nude tude eye shadows
This is the best eye shadow palette out there. Great pigment. Lasts all day. Fantastic swatches for a natural or dramatic look. I cannot recommend this product enough. Very pleased. There is a collection of glitter and matte finishes.

1 review
Physicians Formula Baked Oatmeal Wet/Dry Eyeshadow
This is a great eyeshadow, it comes in a little compact with 3 different colored palettes. What I like most about this eyeshadow is that it is a wet or dry formula. If you want a subtle look, apply the eyeshadow dry. Its shimmery and well pigmented. If you want a dramatic look...

1 review
maybelline new york color tattoo
I have this in toughest taupe. I can say that this lasts forever, and the color payoff is amazing, so much so that I like using it as a eyeliner sometimes, and its stays on.

2 reviews
wet n wild Color Icon in Silent Treatment
Love the warm, shimmery shades...easy to apply...but crumbled in the container. Still used it but became a bit messy...for the price, it was a score!

2 reviews
L'Oreal Colour Infaillible
I purchased the Amber Rush shade a few weeks ago and I am very happy with it! I recommend putting a thin layer on as it goes on extremely well! I will probably purchase more shades soon!

2 reviews
smash box Soft Box Eyeshadows
PHOTO OP EYE SHADOW PALETTE IN SOFTBOX II Best 6 shades to create any look !!!!

1 review
Maybelline Chai Latte Eyeshadow Quad
I heard of this product from a makeup Guru and I have seen it at department stores. However I was always curious and a little hesitate about this product since it is a drugstore brand. I have had a reaction to drugstore eye shadows back in the day and I have always been scared...

1 review
NYX glam shadow
These shadows have brilliant shine and shimmer. The store where I got mine only had neutral colours, which was sad because they would be awesome in vibrant colours. This products lasted a long time on my eyes, which made me happy since I only paid 4.00 for the product.

1 review
Essence eyeshadow collection cookies&cream;
It´s a baked eyeshadow ultra silky smooth texture easy to Apply . Mine is color #02 macaron, c'est bon ! ( french color name )its a 1,5g size. Cost 2,49$ canadian $$ .Cons: need to wear a eyeshadow primer if you want to keep the color for the day long ! I love this company !

1 review
The Body Shop Colour Crush Eyeshadow
The Body Shop Colour Crush Eyeshadow in the shade 201 - Melt My Heart Shade 201 - Melt My Heart, it's bronze colour & has a shimmery finish. Super pigmented & is super soft. If you're to swatch it with your finger it feels like silk. It's a very high quality eyeshadow. Also...

1 review
Revlon Photoready Eyeshadow
I really like this eye shadow, it's laid out perfectly with great instructions! I don't need to have several separate cases and it stays on nice!

10 reviews
clinique colour surge eye shadow duo in like mink
I LOVE this eyeshadow! The colour work great together, it is a high quality shadow and stays on. Plus it comes in a super stylish case that won't break on the go! I have other shadows but rarely stray from this one.

1 review
Maybelline Expertwear Eye Shadow
Absoultly love it !!!! It lasts all day comes off easily , awesome choice in shades to choose from. Unless something better comes out I won't buy any other eye shadow.

13 reviews
mac extra dimension eye shadow
I own a limited edition color, golden pewter. These eyeshadows are AMAZING. By far the best I've ever used. The texture is very smooth, but stays on your eyelids. The application is phenomenal. Applying a single swipe of this eyeshadow makes it appear as though you did a full...

1 review

The Hot List

Trending products on ChickAdvisor curated by our members & advisors.