Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Find reviews on:
Category:
Sort by:  
DateRating

41-60 of 1060

CoverGirl Eye Shadow Palette
very nice colors. buildable, and well priced. I do love cover girl and the eyeshadow is no exception great for trying a new color you're unsure of or great price for people like me that can't afford 75 bucks for eyeshadow


10 reviews
Kat Von D Shade & Light Eye Contour Palette
Although Kat VonD products seem to be a little on the pricey side, they definitely do deliver! All of the shadows are highly pigmented, and they compliment any skin tone/shade perfectly. I love that they are very buttery, and glide on very easy, and are easy to also blend on the...


4 reviews
Mary Kay at Play Neopolitan Baked Eye Trio
I bought this and got 3 years out if it till I dropped it. Even then it all didn't shatter and go everywhere. Color very nice perfect for sensitive skin. And color stayed a day. Also I found the colors didn't blend together


9 reviews
Covergirl TruNaked The Goldens Eyeshadow
I've never been a fan of covergirl but after I got the opportunity to try this palette I ended up loving it. I find that the shadows apply beautifully wet especially the champagne colour. The formula is very blendable and is great for everyday wear.


4 reviews
Covergirl eye enchancers shimmering onx
I don't wear make up very often and when I do I have to get someone else to put it on me because I'm clueless when applying makeup. This was one of the first eye shadows I purchased and I wanted it for a cat eye look and it looked really nice when it was applied (by someone...


1 review
Pacifica natural mineral eye shadow trio
I am not normally an eye shadow person I received this one in my ipsy bag I was happy to try it. It went on nicely and looked great. I like the fact it is 100% vegan and cruelty free. It lasted throughout the day Looking fresh like I had just applied it,


1 review
Kiko Milano Water Eyeshadow
This particular eye shadow can be applied both wet and dry, so it is versatile, and can easily be dressed up or down. When used wet, the color is a lot more vibrant ad dramatic, as well I've noticed that the staying power is also greater. When used dry there is a little bit of...


1 review
Maybelline The Rock Nudes Eye Shadow Palette
LOVE this palette! I love eye shadow and am always experimenting with colors, which means I'd have several different ones in my make up bag, this palette combines lots of complimentary colors all in one, easy to mix them all and use - great looks. Drastically reduced what's in...


2 reviews
NYX Cosmetics ipsy eye shadow trio
I got this in my ipsy bag. I wasn't too happy that it was sparkly, as I generally go for matte eyeshadows but I really do love this trio. The shades are great for my coloring and they are long lasting, buildable and have great color payoff. I love using the darkest one as an...


2 reviews
Urban Decay Eye Shadow | Virgin
This eye shadow is $22 for 0.05oz of product at Sephora. Virgin is my favourite colour to use as a base for pretty much every eye look I do. It's great for just simple natural looks, classic winged liner and red lips or a highlight for smoky eyes. Great pigmentation, it's a cool...


1 review
Essence All About Candies Eye Shadow Palette
Essence's All About Candies Eye Shadow Palette contains six smooth texture shadows in fun pastels that range from matte to shimmery metallic. They have fabulous pigmentation and I am so impressed with the quality of this little box of sweetness! I found it at my local Shoppers...


1 review
Colourpop Shadow & Pigments Eyeshadow
For the price of these eye shadows, the quality of these shadows is amazing! They are super pigmented and easy to blend. There is very close to no fallout with this shadows because these shadows have a creamy like consistency without actually being a cream shadow. However...


6 reviews
Lise Watier Palette Simply Nude
J'adore cette palette de couleur. Les pastilles de couleur se marie bien ensemble. Les couleurs tienne toute la journée. Belle qualité de produit pour le prix.


2 reviews
Kat Von D Shade and Light Eye Contour Quad | Smoke
gorgeous, matte finished shades for a variety of different smoky eye looks. Soft, but highly pigmented powder, that blends flawlessly and lasts all day without creasing or fading.


1 review
Urban Decay Ammo Palette
I will preface this by saying that I am not a fan of shadows that require a lot of effort in terms of cleanup, and unfortunately, these shadows have a bit of kick-up and fall out. I prefer shadows that are pigmented with minimal to no fall out, and the shadows in this palette...


12 reviews
Mary Kay 'Iris' mineral eyeshadow
This color is nice and bright. Goes on good and stays. Find it keep shimmer look all day. Also perfect where I have sentive skin and last long time .


2 reviews
Makeupgeek eyeshadows
I'm surprised no one has written about these yet because these are bomb! Highly pigmented and the colour range is extensive. From mattes, foiled shadows, shimmers and duo chrome... anything you want they have it. I heard about these as I watched Marlena from before she had her...


1 review
the nudes maybelline new york
This is a really good option if you're on a budget, it's kind of a cheaper version of the Urban Decay Naked palette, however I don't find that the colours are nearly as pigmented or blend quite as nicely which you probably won't even notice if you've never invested in Urban...


6 reviews
Stilla Eyeshadow Palette in Spirit
This is by far one of the best eyeshadow formulas in the $50 dollar price range! These have great blenability, pigmentation and payoff! Lovely color selection as well!


3 reviews
IT Cosmetic Naturally Pretty Eyeshadow Palette
I had purchased this eye shadow palette on the shopping channel and love all the 14 shades. This palette gives me the option to transform the matte luxe shadows into a pearl finish. I can also apply these shadows wet or as a liner and they go on like butter, no tugging or...


1 review



The Hot List

Trending products on ChickAdvisor curated by our members & advisors.