Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Find reviews on:
Category:
Sort by:  
DateRating

61-80 of 619

Make Up Forever Artist Shadow
The price may be a little high, but make-up forever has awesome pigments that are true to colour. You need very little product to get perfect results and you can build intensity knowing it will stay put all day! Huge fan of the theatrical arts (where this company started their...


2 reviews
mac eyeshawdow
I have been using Mac eyeshadow now for afew years and love Mac products they are simply the best ever. I love how the eye shadow looks when it goes on and stays on all day. Thank You Mac for all your great products I am hooked.


1 review
Sonia kashuk eye shadow palette in eye on neutral
It's an expensive palette at upwards of $25 but it is a dupe for the urban decay naked2 palette which is over $50. The Sonia Kashuk palette is very pigmented and you can choose between a shimmery or matte palette.


1 review
NYX Dream Catcher Palette in dusk till dawn
This palette in the colour dusk till dawn is way better then the maybelline the nudes palette spend you money on a good quality product. Ten eyeshadows heavily pigmented very bendable as well two are matte the rest shimmery. With shades of cream, taupe, gold, coppered browns...


1 review
Clarins Ombre Matte Eyeshadow
Clarins is all about matte for Fall, with six cream to powder shades that are a dream to apply. The texture is super silky, but dry feeling, and apply best with fingers, but still blend out with ease. The shade I've been using is Nude Pink, a pale nude with a touch of a pink...


1 review
Urban Decay Naked 3 Pallette
Very pretty colors. i love all of them


2 reviews
Lorac Pro 2 Palette
The colours in this palette are amazing. Very different, with all cool shades. I enjoy how unique the colours are and the high quality of the pigmentation. This does have quite a bit of fallout, and the shadows are fairly soft so you should be gentle when picking up product.


1 review
Hard Candy Naturally Gorgeous Top Ten Eye Shadow Collection 524
I came across this product randomly at Walmart one day, & boy am I glad that I bought it. Love all of the colors in the palate that I have, they go great with my brown eyes, and I highly recommend it.


1 review
annabelle eyeshadow in Aura
I LOVE THIS EYESHADOW. its so settle yet so nice, its smooth, very pigmented. I love it so much i already finished one and have to buy another


1 review
Revlon ColorStay 16 Hour Eye Shadow
I love Revlon eye shadow!! I have this quad in the shade 500 addictive, it's great for a neutral smoky or a 'no make up, make up look.' The product works really well and lasts a very long time. It's not chalky and it doesn't crease. Overall a great quad for everyday and on the...


5 reviews
The Body Shop Eyeshadow in 05
Love this medium brown color. Goes on well and stays put for a long time. Would repurchase. Good for contouring and can also be used as a bronzer.


1 review
maybelline colour tattoo barely branded
I really like this Maybelline product because I find that it stays on my eyelids without creasing (even though I have oily eyelids!) and the colour payoff is beautiful. Sometimes I wear it on its own and I feel like my eyes look more awake. Definitely recommended to try out.


1 review
shiseido simmering cream eye colour
This is a great creme based eyeshadow. It does not crease and stays put all day. You can also build the coverage. I have this in 4 colours (Moss, Leather, Yuba and Meadow). Yuba and Meadow are my daily go-to's, both are great underneath liquid liner or over an eyeshadow for...


1 review
Stila In the Light Eyeshadow Pallete
I adore this palette! If you can get it on sale, it's definitely great quality for a good price. I got mine during the Boxing Day or Black Friday sale at sephora, and it was heavily discounted. The color and pigment pay off on the shadows is fantastic, and the eyeliner is...


2 reviews
Revlon CustomEyes
I have the 005 Gold Spun eye shadow. There are 5 different colors from black, brown, light brown, gold, and white. The black and brown are pretty pigmented and comes out beautifully when I put them on. The rest except for the white are pretty pigmented as well but not as much as...


1 review
CoverGirl Eyeshadow- Pink Chiffon
Applies easily, sparkly, and looks great with people who have blue eyes!!


1 review
Bare Minerals 5-in-1 BB Advanced Performance Cream Eyeshadow
great feel, my eyelids feel great afterwards! the color is buildable and you can make it as dark or keep it as light as you want. you can paint it on with the wand or blend/smudge it to get the consistency/color you want.


1 review
Mary Kay Eye Palette in Sapphire Noir
Yeah…I love this. Even with the fallout I got from the grey shadow, it was totally fine as a liner when I used it damp. The trio of purple shadows is honestly like nothing I have in my arsenal and that is a tough thing to say! The quality of the shadows was smooth and soft...


1 review
wet n wild eyeshadow palette "comfort zone"
Its amazing how you can create more then 20 looks with just using this palette.Its very inexpensive and last longer.


1 review
MAC Club Eye Shadow
This is a shadow for day or evening. Provides an Iridescent glow of several colours. Must have! Looks great with any eye colour.


1 review



The Hot List

Trending products on ChickAdvisor curated by our members & advisors.