Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Find reviews on:
Category:
Sort by:  
DateRating

61-80 of 705

24h Color Tattoo Metal by Eyestudio
Amazing product and really stays on for 24h.


1 review
Kat Von D Monarch Palette
Omg I just bought this palette at sephora last week and I am so in love with it. I can't stop obsessing over the incredible colour pay off. I usually find with palettes like these I only like a few of the colours and the rest go untouched but this one is definitely different. I...


4 reviews
Dior Couleure Couture Colours Eye Shadow
For the perfect smokey eye, nothing beats Dior. Glides on like silk and the colour lasts all day or night. Beautiful palettes create that red carpet look.


1 review
MAC Cosmetics Pigments
Overall, I'm not a huge fan of pigments, but I love the ones from MAC! The pigments cost $21USD for 4.5g. I have two -- one in Naked (a really pretty matte/satin nude) and Tan (a really unique peachy bronze). The colors are all gorgeous, pigmented, finely milled, and easy to...


1 review
Hard Candy Naturally Gorgeous Top Ten Eye Shadow Collection 524
This palette is awesome ! I bought this at Walmart for only five dollars . Even though it is very inexpensive is works great ! The colors go on smoothly and last a very long time .


3 reviews
Anastasia Beverly Hills Tamanna Eye Shadow Palette
After reading rave reviews about the Anastasia Beverly Hills Tamanna limited edition Eye Shadow Palette I had to purchase one myself. Having a medium/olive colour skin tone, this eye shadow palette gave me 10 beautiful colours to work with. A perfect blend of neutral to...


1 review
kozmic colours eyeshadow
long lasting, nice selection of colors! I got the one with all the purples in it :)


1 review
NYX Hot Singles Eyeshadow
Comparable to Annabelle and Quo in terms of quality. Colour saturation can be inconsistent among colours - I have some of the 'old' square shaped containers of singles as well as some palettes from the company. A wide variety of colours, and when on sale a real deal. My only...


2 reviews
Almay Intense I-Color Smokey-I Eye Shadow Kit
Amazing product. I am NO makeup artist by any means but this eye shadow is so easy to use it looks like I actually know what I am doing. The colour of the shadow really enhances my hazel eyes and makes the green in them show nicely.


3 reviews
Kat Von D Chrysalis Palette
This palette is so beautiful! It includes hues of purple, grey/silver to navy. The Colors are organized into sets of 3 within the palette giving a hint of inspiration for looks. They included 3 larger size highlight colors which is nice because these usually run out first I...


1 review
NARS Matte Eye Shadow in Coconut Grove
Think of the colour of the outside of a coconut: a deep brown right? This is the exact colour of what this eye shadow delivers! It is super pigmented so you can skip that extra step of wetting your brush to allow the colour to stick. Coconut Grove is completely matte so it is...


1 review
Color Pop Eyeshadows
I have heard such great things about these eyeshadows from Colour Pop but I was never quite convinced. How good could an eyeshadow really be after all? Aren’t they all the same? NO. The answer is definitely no. These eyeshadows from Colour Pop are like no other shadows...


1 review
MAC Cosmetics Pro Pigment Powder in Melon
Mac pro pigment powder in MELON is seriously one of the BEST highlighters I have ever used. Put it on your cheekbones, brow bones, inner eyes, and cupids bow and BLAMMO! You're all lit up, in all the right places! Its flattering for all skin tones, and you can wear it heavy, or...


1 review
Smashbox Cherry Smoke Photo Op Eyeshadow Palette
I bought this on a whim because I am a die hard MAC user but I have to say, this product converted me in the sense that I want to now purchase more eye shadows by Smashbox. The pigmentation, in my opinion is so incredible with very little fallout. I'm a fan now!


2 reviews
Lorac Pro Palette
I finally got my hands on this palette a few months ago & WOW! The eyeshadows are sooo pigmented and the variety of colours are just right for those who enjoy nude or subtle colours. There's a bit of fallout with the darker matte colours, but it's not too much that would ruin...


9 reviews
Maybelline Colour Tattoo Leather
Whenever Maybelline comes out with new colour tattoos I make sure I get them because they are beautiful. The "leather" ones are nice. I like the chocolate suede one the best, the others I found were not as pigmented as the original line (for example the purple one I don't...


3 reviews
Nya eye primer
Low cost eye primer. Matificaze all the eye and your shadows have more durability


1 review
essence All About Paradise Eye Shadow Palette
When I first ought this eyeshadow pallette, I was a little nervous. The colors were beautiful, but they weren't colors I normally used. However, with all the excellent results I have experienced with Essence before, I was willing to take the wild side and try it. When I first...


1 review
The Nude Tude Palette by The Balm
Santa was so good to me this year! I also received The Nude Tude Palette by The Balm. These are 12 fun shadows in a kit (similar to the Naked Palettes by NARS). I found them to be quite pigmented and easy to apply smoothly. A great value and variety for the price.


1 review
Mica Beauty Mineral Eyeshadow
Another Ipsy find. Not certain I would purchase just because it's mineral based, but a good quality shadow with high intense colours, and after seeing on their website that they have 'stacks' of fun bold colours, I might consider at a later date.


2 reviews



The Hot List

Trending products on ChickAdvisor curated by our members & advisors.