Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Find reviews on:
Sort by:  

61-80 of 609

Revlon ColorStay 16 Hour Eye Shadow
I love Revlon eye shadow!! I have this quad in the shade 500 addictive, it's great for a neutral smoky or a 'no make up, make up look.' The product works really well and lasts a very long time. It's not chalky and it doesn't crease. Overall a great quad for everyday and on the...

5 reviews
The Body Shop Eyeshadow in 05
Love this medium brown color. Goes on well and stays put for a long time. Would repurchase. Good for contouring and can also be used as a bronzer.

1 review
maybelline colour tattoo barely branded
I really like this Maybelline product because I find that it stays on my eyelids without creasing (even though I have oily eyelids!) and the colour payoff is beautiful. Sometimes I wear it on its own and I feel like my eyes look more awake. Definitely recommended to try out.

1 review
shiseido simmering cream eye colour
This is a great creme based eyeshadow. It does not crease and stays put all day. You can also build the coverage. I have this in 4 colours (Moss, Leather, Yuba and Meadow). Yuba and Meadow are my daily go-to's, both are great underneath liquid liner or over an eyeshadow for...

1 review
Revlon CustomEyes
I have the 005 Gold Spun eye shadow. There are 5 different colors from black, brown, light brown, gold, and white. The black and brown are pretty pigmented and comes out beautifully when I put them on. The rest except for the white are pretty pigmented as well but not as much as...

1 review
CoverGirl Eyeshadow- Pink Chiffon
Applies easily, sparkly, and looks great with people who have blue eyes!!

1 review
Bare Minerals 5-in-1 BB Advanced Performance Cream Eyeshadow
great feel, my eyelids feel great afterwards! the color is buildable and you can make it as dark or keep it as light as you want. you can paint it on with the wand or blend/smudge it to get the consistency/color you want.

1 review
Mary Kay Eye Palette in Sapphire Noir
Yeah…I love this. Even with the fallout I got from the grey shadow, it was totally fine as a liner when I used it damp. The trio of purple shadows is honestly like nothing I have in my arsenal and that is a tough thing to say! The quality of the shadows was smooth and soft...

1 review
wet n wild eyeshadow palette "comfort zone"
Its amazing how you can create more then 20 looks with just using this palette.Its very inexpensive and last longer.

1 review
MAC Club Eye Shadow
This is a shadow for day or evening. Provides an Iridescent glow of several colours. Must have! Looks great with any eye colour.

1 review
MAC Vex Eye Shadow
This eye shadow is a staple in your make-up case. You can use it everyday and it is very versatile. Looks good with any skin tone.

1 review
Too Faced Eye Love palette.
I purchased the Too Faced Eye Love palette off Ebay for $15.00. Let's realize what a deal that is first. If your familiar with Too Faced products or not, you'll love this palette. The palette is a little larger than my iPhone 5, inside of it are 8 beautiful shadows. The idea...

1 review
Nars Kalahari
Love Love this Color duo! Long lasting and always get tons of compliments!!

1 review
Smashbox Wondervision Mega Palette 2013
Shadows have great pigment and are super soft. Mix of matte and shimmers. Blushes have great colour but a little dry of a formula. Bronzer is matte. Blends very well.

1 review
CLINIQUE Chubby Stick Shadow Tint For Eyes
A cross between an eye shadow and liner - great blendability and lasting colour - may crease if it's really humid out. I have put a translucent powder over top to help set - seems to work. :) Great colours too.

1 review
NYC Sparkle Eye Dust Pink Champagne
I love this stuff, always wear it every day! I only put the price for the review as average, because it was a gift from a friend. I still highly recommend it though!

1 review
Coastal Scents Winterberry Palette
I purchased this eye palette as my first purchase from this company. For the price $12.95, it is amazing. The colours are vibrant and last all day. I will purchase more makeup from this company.

1 review
Essence Mono Eyeshadow
If you're undecided about a colour, or want to try out make up and not spend a lot, Essence is worth a look. I have not loved their lip gloss, and have not tried any mascara, or face make up, but am a fan of their eyeshadow, in particular anything with a bit of shimmer...

1 review
Bone bell powder eye shadow
Cafe shade is my everyday go to shadow. I use it to cover my entire lid. It's the perfectly sheer but with a lovely rich of colour to use as a base for other shades. Great for the base of a smoky eye. Even on its own it's nice. Makes the inside corner of my eyes pop like crazy...

1 review
Barry m dazzle dust
One of my favourites in my makeup bag. Jet back, perfect amount of sparkle- not cheap looking at all. Goes on best with an angled eye brush. Does the smoky eye better than anything. Great product.

1 review

The Hot List

Trending products on ChickAdvisor curated by our members & advisors.