Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Find reviews on:
Category:
Sort by:  
DateRating

61-80 of 693

MAC Cosmetics Pro Pigment Powder in Melon
Mac pro pigment powder in MELON is seriously one of the BEST highlighters I have ever used. Put it on your cheekbones, brow bones, inner eyes, and cupids bow and BLAMMO! You're all lit up, in all the right places! Its flattering for all skin tones, and you can wear it heavy, or...


1 review
Urban Decay Naked 2 Eyeshadow Pallet
Dont know what took me so long to buy this palette. Its absolutely perfect for work during the day and at night!. Definitely would recommend it to anyone thinking about it. Worth every dollar.


2 reviews
Lorac Pro Palette
I finally got my hands on this palette a few months ago & WOW! The eyeshadows are sooo pigmented and the variety of colours are just right for those who enjoy nude or subtle colours. There's a bit of fallout with the darker matte colours, but it's not too much that would ruin...


9 reviews
Maybelline Colour Tattoo Leather
Whenever Maybelline comes out with new colour tattoos I make sure I get them because they are beautiful. The "leather" ones are nice. I like the chocolate suede one the best, the others I found were not as pigmented as the original line (for example the purple one I don't...


3 reviews
Make Up Forever Artist Shadow
The three Artist Shadows I have all swatched and applied beautifully. Colour payoff was what I would expect for a $25 eyeshadow, but I expect that there might be some other finishes that may have either more fall-out or aren’t quite as pigmented. Such is the way of eyeshadows...


4 reviews
Nya eye primer
Low cost eye primer. Matificaze all the eye and your shadows have more durability


1 review
essence All About Paradise Eyeshadow
When I first ought this eyeshadow pallette, I was a little nervous. The colors were beautiful, but they weren't colors I normally used. However, with all the excellent results I have experienced with Essence before, I was willing to take the wild side and try it. When I first...


1 review
The Nude Tude Palette by The Balm
Santa was so good to me this year! I also received The Nude Tude Palette by The Balm. These are 12 fun shadows in a kit (similar to the Naked Palettes by NARS). I found them to be quite pigmented and easy to apply smoothly. A great value and variety for the price.


1 review
Mica Beauty Mineral Eyeshadow
Another Ipsy find. Not certain I would purchase just because it's mineral based, but a good quality shadow with high intense colours, and after seeing on their website that they have 'stacks' of fun bold colours, I might consider at a later date.


2 reviews
Wet N Wild Color Icon Single Shadow
This is a good eyeshadow to get if you're looking for a fast and cheap alternative. It gives ggod color but it's way better if you use a primer before the eyeshadow.


2 reviews
Flower Beauty Shadow Play Eyeshadow Quad
I bought this eyeshadow in the colour "Foxy Browns" because it has 4 really pretty neutral and classic colours that go well together. The quality was great although they're slightly more on the powdery side, so there may be some fallout. The packaging definitely looks nicer...


1 review
L'Oreal Paris La Couleur Infallible 24HR Eye Shadow
Love the boldness of the colour. Easy to apply


21 reviews
MAC Cosmetics Pigment in Vanilla
Love it, the color is great! And I like the powder


2 reviews
Lorac Mega Pro Palette
Despite the "powdery" shadows, as some people may describe them, these are soooooo beautiful and very effective. I use dusty plum from the palette... every day. I'm starstruck. The only complain that I have is that they do not have Lorac in Canada, so it was very expensive for...


2 reviews
Ulta Eyeshadow
These are Ulta's house brand eyeshadows. To my surprise, I LOVE them. I have four now (Naked, Buttercream, Sandstone, & Bermuda Sand), and will definitely be buying more. These cost about $7.00USD and you get 2.4g, but they're almost always on sale for $3USD each. These shadows...


1 review
Lorac 3D Liquid Luster
Liquid luster is simply amazing. Wear it alone or over your shadow and transform any look into a complete glam affair!! So shimmery and beautiful and the shimmer stays put! Love love love!


1 review
MAC Cosmetics Pigment in Vanilla
I use this pigment powder tub everyday. I add a little bit in the inner corners of my eyes and it brightens my eyes and makes them a little more awake looking. I also use it occasionally as eyeshadow and it never creases and goes on well. This tub also lasts a long time. If mine...


1 review
Bobbi brown sand eye palette
Absolutely gorgeous palette! Amazing colour payoff. Pretty neutrals with glitter/shimmer.


1 review
Almay intense i-color powder shadow smoky-i for hazels
The perfect smoky eye! I really love the way my eyes look when I use this blend of eyeshadow. It's great for a night out on the town.


1 review
Rimmel London ScandalEyes Shadow Stick in Bad Girl Bronze
I got this eyeshadow stick a month ago and I've been using it constantly. The colour is more brown than it is bronze and it is gorgeous. I usually put it over my eyelid and then smudge it out with a brush. The colour lasts pretty much all day and it doesn't crease on me...


1 review



The Hot List

Trending products on ChickAdvisor curated by our members & advisors.