Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Find reviews on:
Sort by:  

61-80 of 520

Mally Evercolor Shadow Sticks
I've seen tons of gurus on Youtube raving about Mally's Evercolor Shadow Sticks ... What are Mally Evercolor Shadow Sticks? Well they serve as a primer, shadow, smudgy eyeliner, and eyeshadow brush in one. Application is easy--just line eyes and fill in the lid. You have about...

1 review
STILA Magnificent Metals Foil Finish Eye Shadow
I have the Kitten - nude pink sheen. The metallic colour is radiant and shimmery. Love it! However, it's a bit difficult to use/apply it. Also it comes with a mini jar of eye primer. It's interesting to try out something unique.

1 review
Younique Mineral Pigment
Younique mineral pigments are phenomenal!!!! They are 100 percent natural, chemical free, mineral based, free of talc, oils perfumes. Synthetic dyes and parabens!!!! These pigments have many different uses you can use them dry as a shimmery shadow, wet for a more dramatic...

2 reviews
MAC All That Glitters Eyeshadow
Very good product for the stay of the makeup on the eye it's stay every day without going all over the face :)

10 reviews
Kat Von D Spellbinding Book of Shadows
Love this book of shadows!! A great mix of glitter, matte and iridescent shadows that give you a great idea of what Kat offers. I do find her smaller shadow mix collections have a higher pigmentation. But for a holiday book, my verdict is awesome!! Diggin' the gold and pinks...

2 reviews
Urban Decay Shadow Palette - FUN
I got a REALLY awesome deal on this palette today and I am HEAD OVER HEELS LADIES!!! This Palette is GORGEOUS! It comes in a little case with an awesome little design, It has a magnet holding it in the case which is functional and fabulous! The shadow is BRIGHT and BEAUTIFUL!...

1 review
NYC HD Trio Eye Shadow
For $2.99 this eye shadow is worth it! I got a complimentary sample of it in Long Beach Sands. I always wear 3 shades and I love these colors blended together. They work well together and they last a long time. I can't wait to try others!

1 review
Mac Eye Shadow - Pink Freeze Frost
I am addicted to cosmetics...today was no exception. I stopped to grab eye lash glue and bam two great colours screamed "take me, take me". Pink Freeze Frost is stunning. Don't be fooled by the strong colour on the shelf. It is just the right wash of colour when applied. It...

1 review
NYC Individual Eyes Green Eyes
I love this palette because it has the labels of what the product can/is made for. So it's perfect for beginners or people who don't know all that much about makeup. So they make it super easy for anyone & it's perfect for on-the-go because the pallet comes with the primer...

1 review
Sleek iDivine Eyeshadow Palette
I have this palette in Oh so special. Its one of the better neutral palettes that I have come across. The fall out is minimal, the shadows creamy and super blendable. Great product

2 reviews
Stila In the Moment Eye Shadow Palette
PROS: Highly pigmented, goes on smooth, full size eyeliner included, comes with look book This palette is filled with beautiful colors focused on purples that are just stunning! This eyeshadow goes on smooth and lasts all day (with appropriate primer). The colors are bold and...

1 review
e.l.f Essential Flawless Eye-shadow palettes
I think this is a great eyeshadow quad, it is so inexpensive, yet the color payoff is great. I do find that these colors are not particularly long lasting and are somewhat powdery, but eyeshadow primer seems to counter this. I really like the butternut quad especially as it is...

2 reviews
Maybelline EyeStudio Color Tattoo Cream EyeShadow
I had higher hopes for this eyeshadow. It creased, it was cakey, it didn't last long, it ran/smeared. Very disappointed.

13 reviews
Avon Cosmic Eyeshadow
Another of my recent purchases from Avon, their baked Cosmic Eyeshadow appears to be absolutely gorgeous, but I just could not put five stars on any aspect of it and I'll explain why. The price seemed a little high for what I felt was a rather small compact of makeup, but maybe...

1 review
Bonne bell eyeplayset
I don't use bonne bell products much anymore, except these. This brand was one of the only ones I used as a pre-teen, as I was only able to wear lip balm/gloss. I always loved the flavors too. I also love the fact that this brand does not test on animals. This palette consists...

1 review
Physicians Formula Eyebrightener Multi-Colored Eyelighter
I have dark lids and this really brightened up that area. It is multi-colored but doesn't give a ton of color. It is pearlescent and shimmery, and is long lasting. Although I don't care for the brush and use my own applicator, I would recommend if you have dark lids.

1 review
QUO eyeshadow
i like these eyeshadows but they are fairly pricey and i feel there is nothing special about them.

2 reviews
CoverGirl Stack-ups Shimmer Dust
I use this product to blend an expresso eyeshadow in my crease. I've gotten a lot of compliments on the shimmer, it's just enough to make you look ready for a night out but work for day as well

1 review
Lorac Pro Palette
I love this, I like that it has matte and shimmer shades. Good for creating simple or dramatic looks.

3 reviews
Clinique Contour colour surge eye shadow trio
This 3-step (base, contour and definer) system is stunning. Even for those of us who have little time in the morning, you'll leave the house looking and feeling very glamorous. The slate/lilic truffle is my favorite.

1 review

The Hot List

Trending products on ChickAdvisor curated by our members & advisors.