Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Find reviews on:
Sort by:  

61-80 of 495

Hard candy naturally gorgeous
I just love it, I found it one time at Walmart and bought it I was very impress by the quality of it. It went nicely on and lasted all day long. I bought one of the palettes and I love the colors and the way it looks.

2 reviews
MAC Eye Shadow - Parfait Amour Frost
Mac got me again...I only intended to purchase eye lash glue (which is amazing) and I couldn't resist this shadow. I love strong colours and this one qualifies. This purple is over the top and paired with pink freeze makes for a stunning combination. You will have to be a...

1 review
MAC "all that glitters" eyeshadow
These eyeshadow shades are fantastic. I found out that they have a pretty long wear time when I ran out of eyeliner for a week. I used a black/red sparkle incrusted shade while dabbing water on my eyeshadow brush and lined my waterline. It lasted all day and looked amazing. Not...

8 reviews
Rimmel London ScandalEyes Eye Shadow Stick (Waterproof)
I received this eye shadow stick a little while ago but only recently started using it. Since the first day, I've been wearing it almost continuously. Strictly speaking it's an eye shadow, but it's highly pigmented, waterproof, and shaped like a crayon, so I've been using it as...

1 review
clinique eyeshadow
This is a nice eye shadow that is a bit on the pricier side but gives you a really nice application. I love how the color pops on my eyes making them stand out, when I wear it. This is a bit pricier than the drug store brands, but can be worth the money as you don't need to...

1 review
Almay wake up eyeshadow   primer palette
I love this eyeshadow! I purchased it for a summer wedding I was in and it stayed on all day through out the heat (outdoor wedding). It is also super easy to apply. It tells you which color to put where and the primer really helps the color pop and stay put. The eyeshadow looks...

1 review
Mary Kay Cream Eye Color
I love this eyeshadow, it is definitely the best I have used yet. My eyelids are a bit more oily compared to the rest of my face so I need a primer to keep my shadow on. I love this because it has built in primer! I use the color Violet Storm.

10 reviews
CoverGirl Bombshell Shine Shadow
I'm still kind of on the fence about this product. I have tried it in three shades: a gold, a rose gold (pinkish hue) and the purple. I love the colour range, I'm really into metallics on eyes at the moment (which in itself sounds kind of silly, I realise) but I love the way a...

1 review
 Marc Jacobs Style Eye-Con No. 3 Plush Shadow Eyeshadow
An incredible compact palette! I received “The Mod” #112 to try from ChickAdvisor. The three shadows compliment each other perfectly, eggshell white (matte), black with shimmer (metallic), taupe (sheen). I adore the packaging – it comes in a small pouch, with a starter...

1 review
L.A. splash cosmetics eye sparkle
These eyeshadows are great. They are the one that we used in my cheerleading team so I tell you: they stay in place until YOU decide they go. They are highly pigmented powders that you apply on top of a coat of eyeshadow glue (sold apart). They're AMAZING. great colors and...

1 review
MAC Paints
This is the best eyeshadow I have ever tried and also works well as a base. If you don't take this eye shadow off when you go to bed you wake up looking exactly the same. So worth the money. Just wish they would come out with more colours!

9 reviews
clinique eye shadow in Plum Potion
This is a pricey product but a really nice quality eye shadow that last for hours. I find the plum glides on nicely but lasts for hours and gives a great evening look. The price may be a bit higher than some of the drug store mascaras, however you do get what you pay for, and it...

2 reviews
L'Oreal Paris Color Infallible Eyeshadow
I have these shadows in Bronzed Taupe, Forever Pink, Tender Caramel, Sahara Treasure and Bronze Divine. They are all very pigmented, especially when wet. They do tend to crease sometimes though (on me) even when I use a primer . However, since the colours are so beautiful that...

10 reviews
e.l.f. Mineral Eyeshadow
For $3, you get a very high quality, long lasting eye shadow.

11 reviews
Marcelle Eye Shadow Quad
These cute little eye shadow quads are perfect for making a variety of looks out of one tiny container. I have 2 so far: "nouveau nude", which has nice golds and browns, and "sundance", which has a pink, browns, and burgundy (perfect for fall!). The quality of these is very good...

1 review
MAC PIGMENT - Full Force Violet (Matte Neon Indigo)
The ONLY reason I am not comfortable giving this full star power, is because it's NOT an easy product for people to work with. I am a makeup artist and it's difficult even for me! MAC will suggest products to use with these tough pigments - But I find anything they suggested...

1 review
Essence Stays No Matter What Eyepencil & Shadow
This was actually pretty good for the price. Sometimes i use it as a base but your can totally use it as a shadow which i do when i'm in a rush. It stays well but since it is a cream eyeshadow pencil thing it does crease so you have to put on a eye primer first which you should...

1 review
sleek makeup
Sleek is a product from the UK and its a mineral base products that is totally awesome. Very pigment color fast shipping everything you need for a cheap price. Awesomeness

1 review
bareMinerals Ready Eyeshadow 4.0
This is one of those products I wish I had tried so much sooner- it's just that great! I picked up 'The Happy Place' palette recently when I was looking for something a bit different than the neutral shades I usually wear. The shades in this palette still sort of fall into the...

1 review
Wet 'n Wild Idol Eyes
I LOVE THIS PRODUCT! I put it under every eye look I do! It makes it look so much brighter and also makes it stay on all day long! Not only is it great under other shadows but it is also a beautiful color on its own! I also have 2 other back ups just in case I run out or loose...

8 reviews

The Hot List

Trending products on ChickAdvisor curated by our members & advisors.