ADVISE
The scoop on the latest products and best places
BLOG
The latest trends, tips and news reported
MEET
Give and get advice from our supportive community
GET STARTED

Login with Facebook
or
 

Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Find reviews on:
Category:
Sort by:  
DateRating

1-20 of 436

Biotherm Play On Eyeshadow
I've recently started using Biotherm Eyeshadows and just love them! They go on really smoothly, don't crease and just feel nice and light! I love the fun colors and the fact that they have spa ingredients in them!


1 review
Benefit The Weather Girl Palette
I really enjoyed the design of this product. It so cute how it has "The Weather Girl" look, making it so old school cool. Then I love how it makes your lips so smooth and soft. I wear this every chance I get. The colors are so neutral that they go with every thing. Love it!


2 reviews
Duwop Smoke Kit
I also picked up this product, but in the Olive shade. I love it as soon as I swatched it in the store. A very deep olive with a beautiful pearl sheen to it. Not sparkly. These are available in some Shoppers Drug Marts which have a more varied selection of cosmetics. Mine cost...


2 reviews
MAC Paints
This is the best eyeshadow I have ever tried and also works well as a base. If you don't take this eye shadow off when you go to bed you wake up looking exactly the same. So worth the money. Just wish they would come out with more colours!


9 reviews
Jelly Pong Pong Venus Magical Pearls Makeup
Jelly Pong Pong have recently released their new eye product - Venus. This precious jar of hyper-modern pearls can be used to hightlight cheeks or for eyes. Simply brush over the surface of the pearls for one colour crush one pearl in the palm of your hand to release a second...


1 review
Hard Candy Suede Quartet
I really like this eyeshadow and recommend it! The colors look great together and are very pigmented. Which means you can make it work for day or night depending how much you put on. It really stayed on well all day and didn't crease at all. The blue is a really...


2 reviews
Brown Eyes Palatte by Pop Beauty
To be honest, I was REALLY excited at first when I saw it in the store, and immediately bought it because of how well organized it was. I thought I'd be able to travel with it, have the beauty of many many shadows to choose from, and life would be a fairytale. Not so...


2 reviews
Maybelline Dream Mousse Shadow
I bought this in 3 different shades at my local dollar tree store Silver Halo- its a pretty shimery silver, not really pigmented but you can see the color. 55 Turquoise breeze- love this one! gorgeous turquoise color, pretty good color payoff-shimmery 10 ivory illusion- i...


5 reviews
MAC Eyeshadow
I've never had a problem with any mac eyeshadow or any mac product. they tend to be a little overpriced but are worth the money if you have it to spend.


138 reviews
Eye Colour by The Body Shop
I really like the bodyshop eyeshadows. The girls are usually pretty helpful at helping you find the right colour too. My favourite is shell pink #26 it's light enough for my pale skin but dark enough to be noticeable. I use it with Pink Champagne #37 on the outter corners and I...


2 reviews
Stila pan eyeshadow
Upon hanging in Sephora recently, we met the Stila rep, and she was available for a makeover, so we checked out their product. This eyeshadow was really nice - and loved the sparkle. The colours are varied, and the staying power is long - lasted the entire day! The best...


4 reviews
Clinique Pair of Shades Eye Shadow Duo
These may be the best high end eyeshadows, they're definitely comparable to MAC, super soft, pigmented and have the perfect amount of shimmer. They have a pretty good price, the duos, trios, and quads are definitely worth the money. I currently have 2 duos in Like Mink, a...


2 reviews
Clinique Colour Surge Eye Shadow Soft Shimmer
ive had the lucky penny color for years and its the one i wear everyday for a subtle look. i love how long the color lasts, much longer than any drugstore brand


2 reviews
Pout Eye Shadow Duo
This is a high pigment matt and shimmer eye shadow powder. This eyeshadow blends very easily and is crease free. For those of you who are highly allergic to eyeshadows out there (like me) this stuff does not irritate my eyes at all. I found this product at Sephora. It is a brand...


1 review
Shiseido Silky Eyeshadow Duo
I bought this eyeshadow duo in pearl green and I have to say that it DOES go on silky smooth. This product is high quality and was worth every penny as it did not irritate my highly sensitive eyes at all. I would highly recommend this product to anyone with sensitive eyes but...


1 review
Rimmel Stir It Up Cream Eyeshadow
I didn't realize this was a cream make up when I purchased it, but that was my own fault. The colours don't blend very well. It's messy and difficult to apply well. I found that it looked caked on and I've never used it since trying it after purchasing it. Not...


5 reviews
Rimmel Underground Eyeful Eye Glistener
I have this shade in Green which is a beautiful golden-green mixture. it applies easily, smooth and creamy. It can be a bit messy and smudges a little by the end of the day, but since its shimmery, I don't mind the smudge.


3 reviews
NARS Duo Cream Eyeshadow in Thebes
I had been wanting to get Nars' Duo Cream Eyeshadow in Thebes for a long time and finally the Sephora store in the Eaton Centre finally stocked it. Since I'm a new mom and have no time to fuss with brushes I love how easy to apply it is - swipe swipe and you're done. The colour...


1 review
Clinique Touch Tint For Eyes Shimmer Formula
I didn't have much success with the Touch Tints. I like the concept and the colors were nice, but they just didn't last very well for me. I do have pretty oily skin, so this may be the problem. I've used 2 of them, one nude color that I bought primarily as a shadow base and...


2 reviews
Maybelline New York Expertwear Eye Shadow Quad in Lavender Fields
When I bought this product I was looking for an eyeshadow that could make my eyes look smoky like the magazines. What attracted me to the product is that it clearly tells you written into the eyeshadow what color goes in which area: Lid, Crease, Brow, Outer Corner. I thought...


11 reviews