This is a tough call for me. I love the way this mascara goes on, and how it looks. At first. And then it starts to flake and smudge. I have this in black and in plum, and I end up looking like I've been caught in a coal storm when I wear the black. The flakes are really too much for me. Sad really... 'cause it starts off so well.

The big brush gives great volume to my lashes. There's no flaking and it comes off very easily without breaking my lashes.

i bought a smaller size and i did not find this worth my money. I had to coat my lashes a good 2-3 times and then add something else on top, it didnt feel like mascara. I did notice however when i had to take it off it washed away with no problem.

I love this mascara! It is true Black and it gives great volume and definition. I especially like the big brush and bristles. It sometimes clumps my eyelashes, but there's no flaking. Also, it smudges onto my lower lid sometimes.

I really LOVE this mascara! It makes my lashes big, long, thick and it gives them lots and lots of volume - it's simply just amazing! The brush is really really big, and it seperates the lashes really well. The only bad thing about it is the price, it costs $19... It's kind of pricey in my opinion, but.. On the other hand it's a very very VERY good mascara, and I definitely recmmend it!

You get a big brush, that's great for coverage, smooth and creamy mascara, that's long lasting! Very minimal smudging, and no flaking. While there wasn't this huge volume to it, I felt it was a very good quality mascara!

I instantly fell in love with this mascara. My lashes are long and thin, for a lot of mascaras I've tried this means clumping or sticking together. The brush evenly applies to every lash; no more clumping or sticking together. The finished look is evenly thick and black. This is my favorite mascara I have ever used and always gives me the look I want,I just wish it weren't so expensive.

You get what you pay for--this product is a little more than I like to pay for Mascara but it is amazing--I'd be willing to pay more for this one. It glides on smoothly, stays on all day and night, and comes off hassle free. If you are looking for a new mascara this is the way to go.

I absolutely love this mascara. It's the only one I've found that doesn't make my natural lashes fall out. It makes my naturally long lashes look natural and not too overpowering. It adds just the right amount of length and volume.

I'm a self-proclaimed marketing wh*re. Whenever I see an ad for something, I run out and buy it !!!!! Well I did this with mascara for a while but you know what? I kept going back for the BADgal ! So take it from someone who's tested a whole lotta mascaras - this one is the BOMB !!!