I love benefit mascaras and thought that my holy grail was the They're Real mascara, but this is better and the wand makes lashes more lengthening than They're Real. This does not smudge on me and holds my curl until I remove it.

I curl my lashes before and after application because I have stubborn lashes in my outer corner that will get weighed down by this mascara.

I marked this low only because I was allergic! Besides that, the first time I used it I wasn't wowed with the results, and the brush requires a lot of "technique".. bummer!

one of my favourite mascaras! my eyelashes never keep a curl and these managed to help it keep a curl, feels very light weight and looks very natural (no clumps)

This one is a great mascara. It definitely lifts up your lashes. Also defines them, lengthens them and blackens them without clumping or flaking. Very nice.

I really liked this mascara at first but I'm not amazed by it anymore.
I do like the way it separates my lashes and gives them length.
Doesn't give the lashes much volume. The formula feels "wet".
But it doesn't flake or clump. I would purchase it again but still
looking for a miracle mascara that gives me the volume & length
I want.

Amazing mascara. Makes my lashes look fake! Easy to apply and remove. Not flakey or smudgy. Will not ever use any other mascara. It's expensive but totally worth it

I may be in the minority of not loving this mascara. It's ok, but I don't see the hype. It didn't do anything drastic to my lashes. Just coated them and gave a tiny amount of length. I have other mascaras that I love that give me the 'mascara' look I love...volume and length...really noticeable. Unfortunately, this did not do what I was hoping.

I got this mascara in a Sephora order as a sample first, I knew I would end up buying a full size. The brush is awesome (separates/fans/curls/lengthens at the same time) and the packaging is super cute as well. The only con is that I find it hard to remove at times but with a good makeup remover it isn't overly difficult.

The first couple of times I used this mascara, I had a hard time getting a nice separated lash. It seemed to all clump up at the root of my lashes. After a few tries, I got the hang of the brush. It's really not made for volume so as long as I don't apply it to the very root, it looks really good.

Best mascara I've ever tried. Curls my lashes without using an eyelash curler. Minimal amounts of fallout that flakes through the day. Wand is great for upper and lower lashes