This high end eyeliner did not deliver!

Definitely do not recommend. It does not glide on smoothly and it’s not worth the price. It’s a good concept but definitely a miss. Drugstore eyeliners are way better than this product and it’s less the price.

Easy to apply and stays on all day!

I purchased this as part of the set with the They're Real mascara (my holy grail beauty product) and ended up loving this stuff!

I don't typically wear makeup - just mascara however when I'm going out and feel like I need to look a little more awake I'll apply this stuff. It just glides on so easily without having to tug at my eyelids. Also the applicator is precise and allows me to easily do a winged tip. This stuff doesn't easily smudge like most other eyeliners I've tried. The colour is black and doesn't budge or fade during the day despite the fact that I have oily eyelids.

I have quite a few tubes of this as I bought a few sets however I would definitely repurchase in the future.

Very "meh"

I bought the beyond green shade from Sephora awhile back. I was really excited to try it because I thought it had a marker-tip applicator. Unfortunately, it doesn't. It is a gel liner that comes through a slit in the end. It's not easy to apply. It does stay on through sweat and water though. I won't be buying this product again.

Unintentional Smokey eye with Benefit Pushup Eyeliner

If you're looking for precision, this not the liner for you...if your toddlers need new crayons--hey you can repurpose your $$ purchase!

I tried this and hated it instantly, it feels like goop/crayon and the brush is completely useless as it doesn't allow for a straight line to go anywhere...

I returned the product 1 day after trying it.

Love it -

I love gel liners, and I love liquid pen liners and I think it's genius that they created a two in one to make a Gel liner pen. I really liked the formula, but it was super hard to remove unless used with the remover which I'll be reviewing next. It is a Paraben free formula. It easily hugs the lash line, and it's super long lasting and dries down perfectly. It's sort of more on the matte side, not shiny. It lasts up to 24 hours and is water proof but it should be removed before bedtime to prevent the blocking of pores. The packaging is pretty cool, you twist the base to get the product, it's packaging is also pretty cute, again sleek and 'sexy'. It has an ''AccuFlex™'' tip, it was a slight learning curve but it's actually super easy to use, and easily glides compared to pencils, and easier to work with than a liquid liner since it's a gel and the formula is thicker so there isn't any running. 

There's a lot of bad reviews since most people find it awkward (Again, learning curve) But I actually really liked it and I want to repurchase again to have on hand sense it was so smooth to apply and I loved the formula. There was also no flaking.

However if you like trying new things and funky products I highly suggest and recommend this!.

Not a fan

I ussually love benefit products but this was not for me.It was a cool concept but first off when i tried to use it the product wouldnt come up and the packaging was dificult.Then i found that it was extremely difficult to use and was patchy.I tried it multiple times to give it a chance but no matter how hard i tried i coudnt get the wing right.Im not sure if this was because it was a sample but i didnt like it and im glad that i hadnt purchased it otherwise i think i would have been even more dissapointed.

Terrible!

I was so disappointed when I used this product, as Benefit usually has good quality makeup! It took forever for the eyeliner to actually start coming out of the tip, and then I found it to be dry and crumbly to the point where it would just kind of fall off the tip during application. It did not give a smooth line and I found that it was just a lot of work. If you try and warm it up it does apply more easily, but not all of the time. Overall I think that this was a good idea but in the end it just did not work out as well as I had hoped.

Good god! The purple liner gave me a terrible reaction. As soon as I put it on my eyes started burning. It was so bad, the next day they were crusted over with pus. I don't know what it was, but something in that colour did not agree with me. No issues with the black liner. I did get a refund, so all is well.

This mascara was supposed to make it a lot easier to do a winged liner and I honestly found it a lot harder! The product did not come out very easily and I found that it was clumpy and would drag on my skin.It definitely didn't live up to the high price tag for me.

La couleur est intense, mais pas super facile à utiliser moi qui suis habituer aux eye-liner en pinceau haha
La texture est sympa aussi. Mais je n'en rachèterai pas