Not a win

I wanted to like this mascara but it’s too clumpy. The brush is a bit more curved than what seems necessary as well. Overall the clumpiness is enough for me not to ever buy this product.

Fine lashes still look…fine :(

I have very fine, light lashes and mascara has always been a struggle. Unfortunately, this mascara is no different. The formula is nice in that it goes on smooth with no clumps, so it’s great for colouring my lashes. However, it did not add any noticeable volume or length. Even with multiple coats, I cannot get the same results as my trusted fibre mascara. This mascara does not live up to its name, I only have it 2 stars because of how smooth it went on. But I don’t know who to recommend this to when the purpose is for plumping and it doesn’t do that!

Not a successful marriage of mascara and serum

I used this mascara twice and I don't like it honestly. I hate when I have to write a bad review. It was not at all doing the job as a mascara (fixating, making lashes voluminous and long). It only added some black coloring to my lashes. The worst part is that it doesn't dry out I think because of the hydrating serum which is good if you are using it as a treatment but not good at all if you are wearing it as make up, because and as you see in the picture it does a mess around the eyelid. Also when I happend to accidentally touch my eye it just messes up everything.

Just not great

This is way too natural for my liking. It doesn’t give volume or real length and is t black enough for me. I can’t speak to the serum quality without using it more but I won’t reach for this as it doesn’t live up to the claims. Unfortunately, even though I love covergirl, this isn’t a good mascara

Missed the mark.

I love Covergirl mascaras but this product unfortunately missed the mark for me. It weighed down my lashes and did not add any extra length. Two positives is that it did not smudge throughout the entire day and it was very easy to remove.

Not my favorite mascara

Unfortunately this mascara was not my favorite. It left my lashes looking sparse and stumpy, and the brush is too big, it smeared mascara all over my eyes. It wouldn't have been such an issue but the product doesn't build up quick enough to get enough layers on my lashes to make it worth my while.

I wanted to love it but don't

Received this free from @thisisbutterly, @chickadvisor and @Covergirl to try and review. I wanted to love this mascara knowing its cruelty free and a brand I generally use and trust @covergirl, but it left my lashes feeling dry and looking clumpy. I understand it says to use it for 4 weeks for it to show its full effectiveness of but after 2 it just leaves my lashes a mess. Sorry @covergirl this is not my favourite mascara from you. #covergirl #simplyageless #crueltyfree

To wet and not plumping

I really didn't like this mascara at all, it was really wet and took forever to dry and got all over my eyelids. It also did nothing for my lashes. It did not plump and gave no volume or length.

Not as expected

I got the opportunity to try this mascara for free! Unfortunately it just wasn’t for me. Didn’t go on very nicely and I didn’t like the results. I didn’t notice any plumping or anything. However I do love covergirl!

Not impressed

I expected alot more from this product however it didn't really meet my expectations. For a day to day Mascara sure I could use it. Would I go out and especially look for or buy this product not really