Ive been using this eye liner for years i fall in love more and more every time i apply it! This eye liner gives me that perfect line and it goes on so smooth its really effort less!

THIS IS THE ONE! I have a fatty eyelid so it is always difficult for me to find the perfect upper eyelid liner. I can't use pencil because it smudges, no to the gel pods, and some liquid liners flake off. I purchased this because of the excellent price and haven't used another liner since. I use it everyday to just line my eyelid and it doesn't stray or flake. I love this product and recommend it to anyone!

This is the only eye liner I use. It stays on and doesn't fade through out the day, It has a soft brush so it will not scratch the skin.

I love this liner. Easy to apply exactly where you want it and stays put. I like it much better than the felt tip.

I bought the black mica 0.05 oz for about $8.00 at Shoppers Drug Mart which cones in a gold container. It has no scent and does not bother my sensitive eyes. It provides a very fine line which works great for me in getting that cat eye look and allows you to build to a thick line if desired. Unless you use this regularly, it dray up fast. I would buy it again and would recommend it to others.

One of my recent purchases was the L'oreal Lineur intense brush tip Liquid eye liner in Carbon Black color. It comes in a plain bag bottle wig golden lid. Liner has a long wand with a tiny brush at the end. Best part was that the product one was not he brush tip instead of the wand as well that prevented messy application.
Liner has a wet formula and I found that I had to be really careful with the application, because unless I kept my lids closed for a while it basically gets messy by getting over the rest of the eye. Drying times isn't fast.
I like that it's actually solid black and add definition and is good for a cat eye look and for thick lines.
If you are looking for think and defined lines it's not good at that due to the flimsy brush as it has bristles.

Maybe it's just me but I find it very hard to use. I had trouble tracing a full line, it seemed like the product was too thick, maybe it's because I don't have a very steady hand...

This liner is amazing. Its pigmented and doesn't flake off during the day. One complaint I do have is that the brush doesn't allow for more detailed work and it bends after a while of using it. Also the formula is a bit liquidy but over all its an awesome product. Definitely going to repurchase.

For a liquid liner, I don't like it. I found it to be too watery so I would have to reappy a couple coats. Then it took to long to dry and I would end up liner marks on my eye lids.

This eye liner has amazing staying power, creates a dramatic line for the eyes, and is worth it's price! You can create a subtle or very dramatic look with this liner. Perfect for the night or daytime.