This is my favorite mascara ever! It is so effective. The only downside would have to be the price. I buy it when it's on sale. The white base is totally amazing, it really preps the lashes for the black mascara. Makes my lashes so dark and thick! Love it.

This is the only 'tube' mascara I've been able to find in a drugstore, and it's quite good.
It does not smudge, flake or come off until you take it off, and then the tubes slide off with ease using water and any cleanser.
It doesn't have a long life, but you're supposed to chuck mascara every couple of months anyway, by which time you will be out of this product.

This is so cool as there are two different ends. It works well and leaves me feeling satisfied with how my makeup looks. I will always be on the lookout for this product, especially if it is on sale.

I love tube mascaras. I was using blinc but I was looking for a similar drug store brand and found this. I love it it gives me the same results for a fraction of the price and I love that it's a double ended container. This doesn't smudge and it lasts until I wash it off. If you're new to tubing mascaras don't be freaked out because it looks like all your eyelashes are falling off lol

I love this mascara and have been using it for years ever since it came out. I don't have that many lashes so I don't want to use something waterproof everyday or hard to remove since I'm scared of pulling my lashes out by accident. So I love how this works! First you use one side that has the primer, then you flip the tube and coat it in the mascara which 'tubes' around each lash. It makes my lashes look so long and the best part is how easy it is to remove! You just splash some water on them for a couple seconds and then the 'tubes' slide right off. I love this so much and hope L'oreal makes it forever!

This was the first volume mascara I have used. And loved it! Love how you get both products in the same tube. Even tho it cuts down the amount you get. But you should be replacing your mascara every 4 months anyways. And this will last you 4 month. Total recomend.

This mascara is fantastic for the "on the go gal" The mascara fully comes off with some warm water eliminating any smudging or running mascara. It comes off of lashes like little tubes that coat them. I only use the black half as I find the results are darker.

I did find that this mascara made my eyelashes appear a little longer. But, it was very difficult to get off and chunks of it would slide right off of my lashes, usually taking a couple of eyelashes with it.
I now only use it for a special occasion i.e.: wedding or family photo's etc.

Bought this to change it up a bit from my regular brand.. short lashes is my main issue.. now I will say they definitely lengthen them but I don't find it makes them pop like my usual brand.. I do like that it last all day and nothing during the day makes it come off .. but when I want it off all I need is warm water and the tube things slip right off my lashes very easy and simple so I say I like this mascara but I don't love it !

Love, love love this mascara! I likely will never buy the expensive fake lash mascara only because I am so impressed with the mascara. Applies super easy and looks great!