This has been one of the eyeliners I've loved the most over the years. The shade I have is in Sable, a medium brown color which compliments my fair features. Since some black eyeliners can look very harsh on me, this makes for a very good alternative. The pencil sharpens very well and the tip has hardly ever broken off. Application goes so smoothly as the consistency of the pencil is creamy, therefore, no need to tug at your skin to get it to be precise. The gold cap also makes it easily identifiable in my makeup bag. The MK Eye Defining pencils are definitely a product every makeup lover should try out at least once.