I think the main good thing is the price. If you want a thick line, you need to go over it a few times and it starts to flake off.

I would recommend it based on the price (cheaper then Sephora!) but I don't find it stays on very nice. Liquid liner is difficult so the little brush comes in handy. I think maybe it depends on how oily your skin is. I say, if you are looking for something relatively inexpensive, it might be a good solution.

I bought this product when it first came out and I was immediately hooked! I had a very hard time with stick eye liners, and this cured my problem! smooth to put on, no lumps or shavings, not too greasy either. Definately my favorite product for eyeliners.

If you're on a budget this is a great alternative to some of the higher end gel products out there. I would recommend it, but definitely not the best out there.

This was the first gel liner that I purchased at SDM and I definately don't regret buying this. The brush is soft on the eyelids but firm enough to deliver the liner onto my eye properly. I use it almost everytime I put makeup on and the black colour is really pigmented. I've had the same pot for about 8 months now and it's still almost as creamy as when I first started using the gel liner. Maybe because I have somewhat oily skin, this gel liner starts smudging to the bottom of my eye after several hour, but with a primer the smudging is minimal. I would buy this product again, but I won't next time only because I want to try MAC's Blacktrack Fluid Line.

The product is smooth and easy to apply. I used many other brands (bobbi brown, mac, l'oreal) and the maybelline my better experience. I have sensitive eyes and didn't have any reaction with the product. The color is rich ans stays during the day.

this is a great drugstore alternative to high end gel liners! This one glides on so smooth! no tugging or pulling, has a few other colors to choose from! the finish great, not shiny and lasts threw out the day

I have bought Mac and different brands from Sephora for gel liners and none of them compare to Maybelline's. It is so smooth going on and the colour lasts all day. My eyes water quite a bit during the day and this gel liner didn't move a bit. I paid $10 for this liner but would have paid $30.

This product is really easy to apply and doesn't smudge! Definitely a must try! It is good when you want to be fancier with a cat eye.

This is the only liner that doesn't smudge that I have tried. I absolutely love it!!