One of the best drugstore gel eyeliners I have tried. It's very pigmented and because of its creamy texture, it glides on smoothly without needing to tug too much on your eyelids. Although I use a different brush, the one that comes with the gel liner is fairly decent and usable. You can create thin or thick lines with it. The product has lasted me 5 months and has not yet dried up.

It dries matte which I like because it gives greater definition to your eyes compared to glossy-finish liners. Considering I have hooded and oily lids, this liner has good lasting power on me. I have gone for hours (~5 hours) without it smudging or flaking. I also have to mention that when applying this, use a thin layer and apply a primer underneath. Because this is so pigmented, you don't have to apply multiple layers. The thicker the layer, the more flaking and smudging you will get. This gel liner is also very easy to remove. It comes right off with my make-up remover.

I definitely recommend this product. It's inexpensive but works well and is readily available at most drugstores.

Makeup is not completed without eyeliner, and this eyeliner is wonderful!! I really love the way it is easy to use and the result that it gives as well. I am really happy with it and I recommend it!

This is a great gel liner for drugstore. I use it for my eyebrows as well as mine are dark . I just keep the strokes very light and it does a good job filling it in. As for my eyes, I love how creamy and easy it is to go on. It takes me a minute or less for both eyes to be lined perfectly for the whole day. I really like this product and I like how it hasn't dried out yet.

Considering the price, I would say it's pretty good. It goes on smoothly and very easy to work with. However, it does start smudging down below my eyes after a day's work. The brush that it comes with is also OK, not the best, but not horrible. I hope this doesn't dry out fast, I've been using it for only a week so far.

One thing though, it is extremely hard to remove. perhaps I need to try another make up remover..

One of my must haves!
Goes on smooth, stays on long! The brush makes it SUPER easy to get a desired look.

Only downfall, as with ALL other liners, is it starts to smudge a tad if you cry, Ha!

Not a fan of this eyeliner at all. It smudges easily and doesn't stay put the way I'd like. At first I thought it was because of the brush that came with it, so I started using it with another angled eyeliner brush and it was the same story.
If you're going for a "smudged" or smokey eye look then this can surely give that effect but, if you're going for a clean and precisioned look then steer clear!

Don't buy this!
Smudges and doesn't stay on very long!
Waste of your money!

After MAC Fluidline, this is my go-to eyeliner. It's a fraction of the cost, and almost as effective! I love what a deal you get, considering the brush is included. As long as you apply it carefully and with precision, this liner will last you the entire day. Love the coverage.

I originally purchased this liner in the plum shade. But after loving it I went ahead and bought every color! I find that it's goes on pretty light . If you want a more defined liner then you would have to apply more or stick with a liquid liner. The gel liners are great for daytime looks. The brush makes it a bit easier to apply also.

I love maybelline as stated many times, so of course I tried there new product... It wasnt worth my money and I had a $1.00 off coupon. The black is DULL and eventually doesn't keep going on so smoothly I love liquid eyeliner so maybe it just does'nt effect me as much as a good liquid eyeliner the darker the better.