Very waterproof. Doesn't smudge on lower lashes. Resistant ro crying. Requires makeup remover to remove. Very black. Formula is not too dry and not too wet. Really nice big wand that gives volume and good separation. Product does not dry out very fast, lasted me a long time.

This mascara holds a curl, darkens the lashes, lengthens them, and makes it look like I have more lashes! The appearance of more lashes comes from the fact that it reaches all lashes when applied. It also doesn't clump or look spidery, so that gives the full lash look. I love this mascara!
A con: this waterproof formula is very hard to remove. I use coconut oil to remove the makeup and it's quite difficult. But it does stay on all day without flaking.

Okay, it's not worth it. It clumps and the colour of the actual mascara is a dark grey. That's the only colour available. It's kind of expensive for a mascara, and it is not waterproof. 4/10

My eyelashes never hold a curl, but with this mascara in the waterproof formula the curl lasted all day with zero flaking or falling. It also separated beautifully and gave a great amount of volume.

Hands down, the best mascara I have EVER tried. I have very short, straight hard to curl lashes that grow down! This is the only mascara that has ever held a curl and have flaked off on me! It doesn't clump, it doesn't smudge and best of all it removes EASILY with a waterproof makeup remover! No complaints! Pick it up! Thank me later! Oh and the price is a steal!

I bought this product when it was on sale so I would say for the price it was alright. I have wimpy eyelashes and this mascara didn't really give them the greatest volume. The brush looks like it made out of pine needles and looks weird.

I was looking for new mascara. Bought maybelline the rocket volume express waterproof mascara. Not so expensive, around $6. There is no volume at all, you need to cover several times and it's really hard to take it off with mascara removal.

This Mascara reminds me so much of the Benefit They're Real Mascara. I love it so much. I prefer the Waterproof formula. It holds a curl so wear. When I use this mascara I feel no need to apply false lashes.

This does not clump, it is very buildable and very pigmented. I have no issue with smudging or transfer.

At first i didn't like this mascara because of the wand. I'd always poke myself in the eyes with it. But once i got the hang of it, i adored it immediately. My lashes lookes long and voluminous and the application was nice and creamy. The mascara lasted all day on my lashes and there wasn't to many fallouts.

I love this product This mascara lasts all day and thanks to the waterproof mascara that does not clump in front of it stays in place all day. I LOVE IT