On to my 3rd purchase of it

This is the best eyeliner ever! It lasts a long time even with everyday usage and gives such a sharp wing. It takes a bit of time to get used to the brush but once you get the hang of it you’ll never go back. It gives such a jet black look and its matte which is great and so so so cheap.

Best eyeliner I ever use. Cheap, precise, really dark! everything you want in an eyeliner! I will repurchase this one for sure. It lasts a long time too :)

Ce eye-liner, c'est une merveille! Depuis que je l'ai essayé, je l'ai racheté une bonne dizaine de fois et ce n'est que celui-là que j'utilise maintenant. Je le trouve simple et facile à appliquer grâce au pinceau souple et à la texture. Le noir est très intense et j'aime beaucoup. Il tient incroyablement bien toute la journée. En plus, ce produit est très abordable. Je le recommande fortement!

The best eyeliner I have ever used! It's an amazing quality liner and so worth the value. It costs around $3-$5 depending on where you buy it and works amazing. The texture of the product is almost paint-like which makes for easy application, and dries to a super opaque matte black. The brush tip is super easy to use and makes it easy to create small or dramatic cat eyeliner. The best eyeliner out there, it beats other drugstore and highend products/dupes.

This eyeliner is one of the best eyeliners I've tried. I love how pigmented it is and how long it lasts. The only down side to this eyeliner is that the brush that comes with the tube isn't the best other than that it's a great eyeliner.

I have used this eyeliner faithfully since I was 14 years old. I have not been able to find another liner with a brush as thin and as flexible as this one. It applies the perfect cat eye everytime. Most women probably don't wear eyeliner for 14 hours so my case is rare but I find after the tenth it starts to transfer to the top lid that's my only complaint

I really like this liquid eyeliner from NYC! It lasts forever and it applies very nicely. I find I need a damp q-tip to clean it up a bit under my eyes, but this is defintely one of my favourite eyeliners. It is pretty inexpensive compared to other products out there.

It went on with ease and lasts good. Its cheaper than most and I will buy again. I was able to sleep and wake up and it still was on. I like this product

I love this product ! It is very inexpensive yet it works so well ! The brunch tip is very fine making it easy to create thin lines and it is very easy to control. It is pretty pigmented as well and I have not noticed any cracking or flaking.

You can't go wrong with the price and it works really well. This is the only liquid eyeliner I buy.