Perfect for someone like me who is so woefully inept at doing her liner correctly.Love this pencil.

I like to use the NYX jumbo pencils as bases for providing an extra impact with coloured shadows. They work really well in that sense but I do not use them on their own. I find that they crease and ball up on my eyes and I hate the applicator. I really do not enjoy having to sharpen a pencil. I find it ruins the appearance and overall effectiveness of the product.

I bought an NYX Jumbo Pencil in black to substitute for a shadow. I wanted to have a very dark shade of black that most eyeshadows don't have without the use of primer. I loved it! It was a great dark shade and it even stayed intact on my crease. The only downside is that there's not an endless supply in one pencil!

If you have oily lids, about the only one that will work is Milk. All of the others I've tried crease like crazy. That's with using a good primer, blending, and setting with shadow. I really want to love the other shades I have, but they're too "greasy" for me to use.

Works as an excellent eye shadow base AND primer. The NYX jumbo eye pencil in 'milk' is a very pigmented white base that when you pat any e/s on top of it, it will come out to the truest colour.

Great colour selection, great formula, smooth and easy to apply. But bad for those with sensitive eyes!
That's why I say stay away!

LOVE these! My fave colour is yogurt. I use mine all the time! So easy to apply and I get a lot of compliments whenever I wear it!

I bought this one day because it had a good price at the store and I was needing a base color so I bought the milk . I was really amazed at how well it blended for me and how it kept other shadows in place . I since bought three different shades of this product

Love it ! Lots of colors to choose from. Goes on smooth. Does not bother my eyes! I really really like this one!

For a quick day to day look these are perfect! Just sweep across your eye and you are ready to go! I find for best results you should use an eyeshadow primer. If I don't use a primer I find that it gets clumped in the crease of my lid.