Good product

I bought the Hard Candy 10 shadow palette from walmart in 2009 for under $10. There are quite a variety of colors. They are all fairly dark. It came with a sponge applicator that needs to be replaced after a few uses. It has a mirror in the compact. Overall I have not used it very much, because I am fair skinned. I think someone with a richer skintone would use it more. Overall it is okay value for the money. The amount of pigment shows up with one or two dips in the pot to get the color to show up. It is not tested in animals and is cruelty free.