fantastic

great product, really bold, long lasting and truly is water proof! would highly recommend this product to anyone searching for a good liquid eye liner

The name says it all!

I have been using this eyeliner for years after years of lookimg for the 'one'. It never comes off until i wipe it off and its the perfect shade for me (261 noir)

The worst

It takes forever to dry and when it does it flakes in large chunks. I used a lot of different eyeliners and this is probably the worst one so far. Cheaper stuff is even better than this. Don’t waste money on this. Never getting it again.

My go-to liner

I absolutely love rimmel exaggerate line, never leave home without it! I've tried every brand of liner out there. It's the only piece of makeup I use every single day and it needs to be quick and easy. A lot of brands use hard, difficult colors which require several attempts to draw the desired shade and often leaves far too much room for error. My rimmel liner never fails me, any weather, any time, any day. Perfect application everytime for any look!

Keep coming back to Rimmel!

I have tried different types of eyeliners, in search of the one that stays on all day and that will look bold enough for me. I found this in the Rimmel exaggerate stay sharp eye liner. This is the one that you do not need to sharpen ever. The cap that twists on sharpens the liner. I've tried the $20+ prestige brands and although they may feel creamier upon application, the longevity of the product on my eyes is no different than the Rimmel! With Rimmel costing 1/4 or less of the price of the prestigious brands with no affect on longevity or waterproofness, it's a no brainer to try out Rimmel!!

HORRIBLE!! DON'T BUY THIS

First of all I usually review eye makeup before buying
I saw this liquid eyeliner and I bought it on a whim
I absolutely hated the brush on it
The product itself was horrible when applied and it took too long to dry and if you didnt let it set enough it would smudge
I actually removed it off my eyes and tried a second application and it was still awful
Don't waste your money with this

Horrible

I have used many liquid eyeliners but I found this one was horrible to use. It didn't apply very well at all and it was not black, it appeared almost as a darling grey. I found it flaked after a few hours however even with makeup remover it was very hard to get off.

Average

I found this eyeliner to be slightly less precise than other ones I have used and a little more difficult to use. I like brush applicators, but this one I didn't care for as much. It held mostly throughout the day, but not as well as I had expected. Overall, it is a good product, just a little more difficult to use than others!