I was given this, as well as their moisturizer. I wouldn't normally choose this brand, and buying for myself, I probably won't again. It works pretty good, but I seem to need heaps to remove my mascara.
It was hard deciding whether or not to recommend it, as it is very gentle on my eyes, and has never stung them, but it takes a while and I am keen to try out other brands.
At the beginning I wasn't actually dabbing at my eyes, and after reading the label I started to do that, which made it much more effect.
If you can be bothered taking a little longer to remove your make up, and you want something that is extremly gentle on your eyes then this would be great for you. For me though, this is not it.

This is the second product I have tried from the simple line that I don't care for.I have also tried the refreshing facial gel cleanser.This would remove very minor makeup but I had a hard time removing my mascara and I don't want to use anything around my eye that I have to struggle to remove its such a sensitive spot.. It states its all natural and kind to eyes.It says its Dermatologist tested,Ophthalmologist tested and safe for sensitive eyes.I found this eye makeup remover way to drying and it really made my eyes water and left them feeling irritated .I would not purchase this product again.I usually use Yves Rochers Chamomile eye makeup remover it is also oil free but works so much better and gentler then this simple eye makeup remover.I don't think I will be trying anymore products from this simple line twice burned and not again.